Construction costs are currently skyrocketing

  • Erstellt am 2021-04-23 10:46:58

chand1986

2022-06-24 07:45:54
  • #1
Sorry, but this is not condensed at a pub level, but factually incorrect. The surplus existed in small amounts already during the D-Mark era. An export surplus per se means that the unit labor costs of the surplus country develop weaker measured in dollars than in other countries. Such a thing should actually lead to appreciations. The Bundesbank always resisted this for a long time during the D-Mark era before it happened. With the euro, nothing happens anymore. This has nothing to do with transfers. And also not with the purchase of government bonds.
 

Oetzinger

2022-06-24 08:01:23
  • #2
The transfers to the southern states by the ECB do not disappear just because you deny them. And they prevent the appreciation pressure that the DM used to have.

A significant weakness of the metric export surplus is also that vacation expenses of German tourists abroad are not included. Adjusted for tourism, the surplus is significantly lower. Nevertheless, Germany should rather consume the surplus itself in the form of imports and vacations instead of shifting it through the ECB without expected repayment into the state budgets of the South.
 

chand1986

2022-06-24 08:25:18
  • #3


??

I did not deny anything. I explained that the mechanism is not as you described it. Not even condensed to some simplified level.

The ECB does not influence wage formation in Germany, and if you don’t have your own currency, then wages directly determine labor costs calculated in international currency. Or – to simplify as well: your own fault. No one forces us to generate these surpluses. We could also use the money domestically by giving people what they are deprived of by the non-occurring appreciation.

So many lobbies are against that it does not happen. None of these lobbies have anything to do with the ECB. Fiscal policy remains a matter for the countries, even in the Eurozone.

You can gladly refer to the current account surplus, which includes tourists’ expenditures. That is also gigantic – for decades now, almost. So that argument doesn’t hold; the numbers don’t support it.

Please don’t sell barroom slogans as mere simplifications when they are factually wrong. Einstein’s insight applies: “Make things as simple as possible. But not simpler.”
 

Hausbau 55

2022-06-24 09:12:28
  • #4
Please stop with these daily status reports. First, you are sure that the interest rate is starting to decline. In the next sentence, you express doubts about a possible trend. Simply keep your feet still for a while.
 

Oetzinger

2022-06-24 09:33:15
  • #5
Not when the ECB buys unlimited Southern European bonds and artificially lowers interest rates. On top of that, the extremely high Target balances. This is essentially fiscal policy through the central bank, and thus a clear breach of its mandate. But the motto is "whatever it takes." Of course, the Euro is a flawed construct, as the necessary convergence processes across countries do not take place and the ECB just prints away the problems with its money press. And Germany only has itself to blame; it should incur much more public debt and significantly increase wages and consumption to restore balance. Instead, it chooses indirect money transfers to the South in dizzying amounts. And the South goes bankrupt immediately if these transfers are even slightly reduced. This was seen at the recent emergency meeting of the ECB Council. And yes, this discussion is absolutely on topic here. Because the ECB significantly influences construction prices with bond purchases and interest rates.
 

danielohondo

2022-06-24 09:44:59
  • #6
Did you not understand the purpose of the forum? This is about exchanging opinions. I present mine and others present theirs, which creates a discussion. Otherwise, if you have nothing to contribute to the topic, then simply do not write anything and avoid the topic.
 

Similar topics
27.07.2015Own home: interest rate development / interest rate / interest rate increase / conditions311
14.12.2016First interest rate increase to be recorded19

Oben