Floor plan optimization city villa + fill consideration

  • Erstellt am 2020-01-31 13:29:27

Shiny86

2020-09-25 08:04:33
  • #1


No. I think you just found everything annoying here at some point. I can understand that.
 

11ant

2020-09-25 13:47:49
  • #2
In principle, yes. With a longitudinal/transverse elevation difference of 70/120 cm (about half of which is within the footprint), I saw no topographical indication (and there was no other concrete information) for a mandatory basement. Now I interpret the new information as meaning that the load-bearing soil probably only lies at the depth where you could also lay the floor slab if you were building a house with a basement. Analogous to a car accident damage, so to speak a "economic mandatory basement." However, first I see a significant difference between switching from pile foundation to a useful basement on one hand and the costs of the previous planning’s tonnages being hammered out (just for the back and forth of the stairs and downpipes, one could have planned an entire holiday bungalow with the same manpower!); and second I don’t see the effort of a redesign as worthwhile: practically, you "gain" here only the space of the building services room placed underground, the rest of the basement won’t really be used (with light well excavation for relocating a study the effort would be too great again), so in net effect there would only be a floor plan to "redistribute" with two decimeters less edge length. But then we’d be right back at the exact point where the original poster soon continued to discuss alone! — so this wouldn’t be an opportunity. If the terrain allowed for a living basement and such was desired, the cards would be dealt differently — but that’s not the case. Besides: even in the thread at least the husband eventually did get around to typing himself, which unfortunately is not granted to us here.
 

Shiny86

2020-09-25 13:57:36
  • #3
I simply can't psychologically manage to start from zero. I wouldn't know how and I have no strength left to start anew after such a long time of sketching floor plans. We actually just wanted to build now and have been waiting for the date of the construction kick-off meeting and now this. I have even already planned the kitchen in the meantime and wanted to start planning the laundry room in the utility room. If anything, it will probably be a utility basement. The utility room will become an office/guest room. It's just very cool that there are now 3 downpipes in there. One of them isn't even in a corner. Also annoying.
 

haydee

2020-09-25 14:05:28
  • #4
A utility basement presupposes a benefit. You don't need it. Have them clearly explain why a basement is needed after all, and show the costs with and without a basement.
 

Alessandro

2020-09-25 14:31:55
  • #5
I would also demand a precise comparison of the costs. I simply cannot imagine that due to the unsuitable soil a basement would cost as much as a fill.
 

11ant

2020-09-25 14:37:18
  • #6
If the extra cost is close to zero, the utility may also be close to zero - efficiency turned around
 

Similar topics
17.07.2015Fitness corner in the utility room?27
24.08.2015Bathroom drainage, number of downpipes, pre-walls, etc....27
27.08.20152 full floors, passage to garage, utility room under stairs25
23.05.2017Technology / utility room on the upper floor, opinions?27
08.07.2016Is it permissible to fasten downpipes with insulation dowels?11
06.05.2017Additional utility room on the upper floor for washing machine, etc.13
18.09.2017Underfloor heating also in the technical room / utility room19
08.02.2018Is the utility room sufficient as a storage room as well?22
16.06.2018The heating system does not fit into the utility room as planned27
28.07.2018Is a soundproof door necessary in the utility room? Experiences?22
02.09.2018Painting the utility room - Which paint? Latex paint?16
12.11.2019Cupboard for utility room21
08.02.2023Insulate utility cellar or not?24
08.04.2020Routing of pipes from the utility room to the bathroom23
06.05.2020How can the utility room in the basement be effectively integrated into the thermal envelope?15
17.09.2020House connection pillar in the garden vs. house connection directly in the utility room35
15.07.2020Painting utility room with gypsum plaster - Which color?20
18.09.2020CAT cable in the utility room - not crimped?45
15.09.2021Ikea Pax utility room/laundry room system? - What do you have?64
09.04.2022Floor plan of semi-detached house, 2.5 floors + usable basement71

Oben