Floor plan optimization city villa + fill consideration

  • Erstellt am 2020-01-31 13:29:27

11ant

2020-05-15 00:57:56
  • #1
But while you are fiddling with 149 decimal places here, such essentials have been discussed multiple times here (in threads only about controlled residential ventilation). You would have just needed to hop over the fence. Simply put, "decentralized" means that such a system must be built once in each affected room and operates "standalone," while the central variant only has one control system for the entire house and effectively "pools" its effect in all rooms. Heat recovery is therefore significantly more efficient centrally, but: central also means a squid-like duct system throughout the entire house. That is why only such a drywall-fearless weak checker like your planner is so naïve as to leave this principle decision open until the last minute.
 

Shiny86

2020-05-15 16:06:49
  • #2


I just missed that. I can’t change it. It’s annoying, yes. The decision was not kept open until the last moment. We only just realized that we would prefer to have a central ventilation system.

What do you mean by drywall? Can’t it be done in the floor structure or in the concrete on the walls? Do you inevitably have any boxed enclosures if you only plan it after the layout is completed?

Currently, we have a decentralized ventilation system without heat recovery included in the house prices. A central system with heat recovery would mean an additional cost of 9,500 euros. Is that price okay or overpriced?
 

11ant

2020-05-15 16:24:36
  • #3

Essentially, it takes place in the floor construction. But central is different (= more complex to duct) than decentralized. And you have a planner without a plan, whose spatial imagination can't quite process rethinking a BD into a DD of the floor below. In the plan, this does not yet cause mandatory drywall work, but probably in the then improvised reality.
 

Shiny86

2020-05-15 16:31:13
  • #4


He probably didn't put any more effort into this one version because he thought it wasn't worth it anyway. He was probably already annoyed with us.

What is your advice? To do without the central and take a decentralized one because the planning is easier? Everywhere I read that a central one is to be preferred in new construction.
 

11ant

2020-05-15 21:08:39
  • #5
And now he's back from vacation and ready for new annoyances? No, the decentralized one is not easier to plan: that applies to the breakthroughs, but to the planning of the system as technical stuff, on the contrary. Regarding heat recovery, I already said that the central one is more efficient. Unless at least 30% (by volume) of the rooms are to be excluded, the decentralized one is, in my opinion, advanced nonsense.
 

Shiny86

2020-05-16 00:19:27
  • #6


Because it’s the final stage, maybe he’s putting in more effort to get rid of us?

Do you or anyone else notice anything negative about the attached drawings? BD/DD realistic?

And again about the central unit: what could happen in the worst case with planning errors? I mean, why should there be difficulties with laying it in the ground? How likely is that and how badly would it look then?

 

Similar topics
02.04.2012Ventilation with heat recovery in new buildings11
09.06.2022decentralized ventilation - various manufacturers39
03.07.2013GAS / SOLAR or GAS / Ventilation + Heat Recovery20
31.07.2013Ventilation system with heat recovery - sense or nonsense?18
03.06.2015Controlled residential ventilation with heat recovery --- a confusing maze?12
06.01.2017Quiet decentralized ventilation for new single-family house73
15.09.2022Central controlled residential ventilation with heat recovery: Are rooms individually controllable?20
07.01.2016Controlled residential ventilation yes - heat recovery no - justification in the text!79
18.04.2016Air-water heat pump, mechanical ventilation with heat recovery?17
26.04.2016Warm bedroom in the house with ventilation including heat recovery24
13.02.2017Ventilation in new buildings (central vs. decentralized), noise disturbance69
03.04.2018New building KfW55 with gas, solar, and controlled residential ventilation with heat recovery43
21.12.2017Energy saving regulation with gas boiler and heat recovery ventilation instead of solar?15
27.11.2017Ventilation system with heat recovery, installation location temperature11
09.01.2018Nilan ventilation system with controlled heat recovery29
14.09.2020Experiences with central exhaust system without heat recovery30
31.03.2019Offer for Pluggit KWL - Heat Recovery14
30.04.2019Heat pump or gas with central ventilation system with heat recovery16
25.01.2020Lower indoor temperature after commissioning Controlled ventilation system with heat recovery14

Oben