These are not arguments for a fixed draining area. Quickly rinsed -> the sink is enough for that. Since there is a lack of workspace here, I would also immediately dry and put away freshly rinsed items (because I need the space for other things). Large bowls or pots -> same, I don’t leave that stuff lying around. Fine glasses -> if needed, I place a dish towel underneath; otherwise, I have free space for versatile use and not designated as a draining area. Hot pots -> if you don’t have a stone or ceramic countertop, you have a trivet that you put away when not needed and then have free space again. And nobody said that sink and stove have to be separated. I would ALWAYS want a sink near the stove. Possibly a small prep sink near the stove and the main sink elsewhere. But that is not the topic here. Stove on the island was not the topic either. Although from experience I can say: if planned well, nothing gets splattered. We have the cooktop on the island (because otherwise it would have been in front of the window and I didn’t want splashes on the glass) and nothing splashes, even with quick frying (which we even do without a pan because we have a teppanyaki grill). However, our island is quite large – and has a sink directly by the cooktop. But here I wouldn’t want the cooktop on the island either.