Comments on floor plan design welcome

  • Erstellt am 2020-05-24 10:24:25

pagoni2020

2020-07-27 10:55:19
  • #1
Look, if you have the impression that almost everyone here is just contradicting you foolishly, it could actually be as you believe:


But: At least with 50% probability, it could also be that YOUR standpoint is just as wrong as these people tell you here. Since you apparently almost alone represent your position A but several others, even independently, represent position B, it is significantly more likely that position B might be correct; at least one should give it more weight and reconsider one’s own position A instead of feeling offended or mistreated. BECAUSE: You are here to hear these opinions and not to receive praise.

In your original post, you wrote, among other things, roughly (please correct me if I am misrepresenting this), that back then at the company Stommel Haus the architect had no good ideas and you were dissatisfied (yet you still built with them??). Now, many years later, although you were dissatisfied with this performance back then, you go again to the same company and report again that nothing decent comes from the architect; still, you stick with this company and call all other suggestions for floor plans or house-building companies here in the forum inappropriate, “unobjective” or “without flair”. I believe that in each case you act correctly or too decisively (which does not necessarily have to be bad) and are looking for someone (including now the 2nd architect) who will build IT exactly as you tell them, even if it is widely regarded as nonsense and nonfunctional. At the latest, the floor plan situation you called optimal, where you would almost have to walk around the house in a raincoat because the WC/bathroom is currently occupied in order to be able to use your entire house from the enclosed bedroom, should make crystal clear to you that you have gotten yourself stuck here. But no, after you have “corrected” this nonsense in terms of planning, you explain that the previous nonsense was in fact better (see raincoat).

That reminds me of a wrong-way driver who complains about the many oncoming cars, sorry. We both might be a few days older, which is why we also have the right (or rather take it) to be a bit stranger than some others. Nevertheless, we should be aware of this and our weaknesses and listen to professional and especially neutral advice, even if it does not suit us entirely. I am no floor plan expert and cannot draw, so I am happy to accept help. You clearly have no idea about functional floor plans and should rather acknowledge that and get help than be offended and deny the forum participants their existing, constructive intention to improve your miserable floor plan.
 

neo-sciliar

2020-07-27 11:13:52
  • #2
Hi Pagoni,

I want to disagree with you on some points and explain a few:
- We want to build with Stommel Haus because in addition to the planning, the concept and execution are also of enormous importance. And that suits us better with Stommel Haus than with all the other manufacturers we have seen. In addition, there is regional proximity, so we like to build with Stommel Haus.
- The planner from Stommel Haus supports our project and thinks it’s good. It is here in the forum where I get a lot of criticism. If I didn’t take this seriously and perceive it, I would blindly build with Stommel Haus. But since I value the experience here a lot, and because I know how error-prone the Stommel Haus planning can be, I question the project here.
- It may be that initially it was very, very bumpy with sciliar and this forum. But it would be nice if it could be toned down to a factual level again. Just telling me continuously that it’s rubbish doesn’t help me. I know that by now. However, I also don’t like the floor plans I have seen because they do not meet our expectations at all (which are certainly diverse, but basically clear). If you look at the alleged contradictions and think about them for a minute, they dissolve. And I have explained this here several times already.
- The same applies to the outside door in the bedroom. An emergency is not: the bathroom is locked (because that never happens), but: the smoke detector in the hallway goes off.
- I gladly accept suggestions for improvement. But statements like “this is all rubbish” don’t help me. And if the only improvement here is to better connect the bedroom to the hallway (via the dressing room), then – sorry – our floor plan is already pretty good. However, this does not fit with the general statements here.
 

Alessandro

2020-07-27 11:41:41
  • #3
I would consider whether you might connect the guest WC to the master bathroom (separated). This would save you pipes and the path from the living room and dining room wouldn’t be so far. I would also do without these 2 doors at the kitchen and living room.
 

11ant

2020-07-27 11:43:58
  • #4
Wrong-way drivers are oncoming *SCNR*
 

Alessandro

2020-07-27 11:45:44
  • #5
I am also quite sure that the drawn-in furniture is too small. For example, you have a 13sqm living room with a large couch placed in it. Such a couch will not easily fit in there. Especially not with such a relatively large distance to the TV.
 

neo-sciliar

2020-07-27 11:48:59
  • #6
Thank you, that is valuable. Which 2 doors are you talking about?
 

Similar topics
17.02.2012Floor plan - house with granny flat23
21.02.2012How do you find this floor plan?11
14.01.2013Opinions about the ground floor layout10
20.06.2013Opinion on the floor plan of a planned Bauhaus building23
12.08.2013Opinions on the "House on the Slope" floor plan requested31
16.12.2013Pre-planning with the architect - is having your own floor plan sensible?18
29.01.2014City villa floor plan / Feedback on static analysis, arrangement28
08.03.2014Floor plan new construction - Please provide feedback36
12.06.2016Floor plan city villa house17
13.04.2017Opinions on the house floor plan wanted71
05.11.2017Floor plan of an accessible bungalow229
09.04.2019Single-family house new construction 160 sqm floor plan - Please provide feedback22
30.05.2018Floor plan bungalow approx. 160m² living area20
10.11.2021Floor plan detached house, 2 full floors and a recessed floor65
09.06.2021Feedback on single-family house floor plan, 222 sqm desired46
05.09.2021First floor plan single-family house 190m264
14.07.2021Floor plan design for a single-family house 230-235 m² on two full floors83
02.08.2021Barrier-free single-family house floor plan for aging with parents' bedroom on the ground floor44
22.09.2021Floor plan of bedroom, dressing room, and en suite bathroom36
25.04.2023Enlarging the hallway floor plan REH from 1921: Tips?27

Oben