Are LAN sockets still up-to-date? WLAN/wireless is the future!

  • Erstellt am 2020-01-29 21:06:26

Bookstar

2020-01-29 22:40:03
  • #1
Yes, but the devices are rarely active at the same time and therefore hardly use any data. If you have 3 children and they all stream simultaneously, it might get tight. But for that, you then have one outlet in the room each.
 

rick2018

2020-01-29 22:43:17
  • #2
But the OP questions that. As I understand it, he only wants cans for the APs and nothing else.
 

Scout

2020-01-29 23:02:31
  • #3
WLAN uses a shared medium, whereas a LAN cable is used exclusively – so WLAN can only deliver about 50% net of the gross. Distance, interference, obstacles, etc. reduce this even further. For comparison: LAN cable or Ethernet is at around 90-95%. Always, undisturbed.

Even if one can achieve higher gross data rates and thus higher net values with flagship routers and WLAN adapters, there is no guarantee that this will always remain so. For example, a new router or the faulty microphone of the neighbor or reflections from the newly hung metal-coated mirror in the hallway can already ruin everything again. Although WLAN is now equipped with a fairly broad frequency band, interference can still occur even at 5 GHz. With cables, however, this is almost impossible.
 

opalau

2020-01-29 23:38:34
  • #4
I understand all these theoretical arguments, but at the same time I see the lived practice: In our rental apartment, we have had double network sockets in every room for almost 6 years. Of those in use: 2. The Apple TV is connected directly to the cable at the TV, and when I sit in the study, the MacBook Pro is also connected to the network. The DiskStation is next to the switch and router and is connected directly.

And otherwise? All iOS devices are always on WLAN anyway, the printer is used at most once a month, it probably needs its firmware updates more bandwidth than the print data. Whether our children will ever use devices that have a network connection, I would at least doubt that.

Following the theoretically understandable approach, we have also distributed some sockets in the house again. But my assumption is that many of them will never be used.

And the expected, experienced disadvantage on usage quality? Probably not noticeable.
 

hanse987

2020-01-30 02:36:57
  • #5
For me, LAN belongs where potentially fixed installed devices will be placed and in such quantity that you don’t immediately need a switch on site.

The TV in the living room will have a fixed planned spot. Then there might be media players and a PS4. I would at least install a double socket there, if not even two. Don’t forget rooms like the hobby room and garage. This way it runs throughout the house. Don’t overdo it, but don’t save to death either. Having is better than needing!

Those who rely only on WLAN must implement it perfectly, otherwise you will have problems. You also have to be lucky that the neighborhood doesn’t overcrowd your WLAN channels. In the future, internet connections will be faster and in some computer forums there are already increasing questions about why my WLAN is slower than my internet connection.
 

Bauherr am L

2020-01-30 07:42:40
  • #6
I see it exactly like :

Many theoretical arguments for LAN sockets are not used in real life.

I don’t even question the TV in the living room. One or maybe two potential TV locations should (at least currently) still be equipped with LAN. But even there the demand is decreasing. A few years ago you would have connected TV, Fire TV Stick, PS4, Apple TV, etc. Today at most a current flat TV plus one other device, because these usually cover everything from Prime, Netflix, etc.
Finding the right spots gets more difficult when you think about a screen and projector.

In the rooms I find it very complex to find the right locations. Connecting a non-moving printer and a NAS to the LAN is nice, too. But with the printer it probably doesn’t matter (Otto hardly uses any bandwidth here) and the NAS, like other devices you don’t have to personally access, just goes next to the switch in the tech room.
Basically, only TVs and (possibly) game consoles remain in the rooms, which are less or not mobile. For these, one might consider a duplex socket.
The spot is always wrong in the end and I have the feeling that the youth of (today and) tomorrow will rather use their mobile devices (smartphone, tablet, laptop, etc.) on their laps. In the 90s and 00s the (initially) tube TV was still the adolescent’s wet dream.

The argument comparing to power outlets doesn’t fit of course. You still need a cable for power. But not anymore for data.

Conclusion: if you are serious about sockets, then you would have to equip all locations where a desk or a TV could possibly be with at least duplex sockets. That already results in a considerable number of dusty and not exactly attractive sockets.
I claim instead that investing in a decent WLAN (good access points via LAN PoE, etc.) is more sensible nowadays for the average Otto-consumer.
 

Similar topics
06.02.2014Location of Wi-Fi router in the attic?18
04.07.2016WLAN repeater or access point?25
02.05.2017LAN / WLAN / Telephone - looking for suitable hardware components23
11.05.2017Improve Wi-Fi range/coverage14
09.06.2017Computer cables and Wi-Fi router43
04.12.2017Fiber to Home FTTH - WLAN Router, Landline Phone, PC53
21.09.2017Electrical planning - How many sockets are enough?120
01.12.2017Number of RJ-45 sockets "network sockets" - What makes sense?62
19.02.2018UPT cable - What is it and where to install?10
27.08.2018LAN, WLAN, bandwidths and contents?92
06.12.2020Number of network sockets; how to plan Wi-Fi in the new building?145
07.09.2021Wi-Fi New Construction - Network Sockets/Cables53
28.05.2020Switch with separate installation for SFP / SFP+33
16.08.2020LAN Duplex or Gigabit Switch13
01.09.2020Which conduit for LAN cable?32
23.11.2020Poor WiFi in the new building despite fiber optics78
11.09.2021Which Cat cables should be installed on the facade? Problems with moisture?29
18.02.2022Which internet Wi-Fi mesh system?49
28.11.2022Do you need LAN cables in the garage?107
18.02.2023LAN and Wi-Fi "devices" per floor?39

Oben