Single-family house plot purchased opinion on architect drawing

  • Erstellt am 2020-07-15 22:45:04

11ant

2020-07-21 15:15:05
  • #1

Exactly following this logic, it is indeed good and right to eliminate the McMansion Hell bay window

Full agreement – however, I find the less conspicuous of the two bay windows here – namely the utility room extended stubbornly with a saddle chamber secondary use to make it meaningful – just as stupid as the "Gelsenkirchen" one.

Thanks for the hint about Trivselhus. But I find nothing traditionally Swedish about the design presented by the OP, that’s why I wrote "scandimerican". Somewhere on the journey from Sweden to the USA it seems to me we have landed here in Rose Nylund’s St. Olaf – and so stylistically the design is as inhomogeneous as the shared flat of Blanche, Rose, Dorothy, and Sophia.

I only wanted to point out that even what is currently considered smart and farsighted – “thinking about the walker at thirty” – will not remain universally valid, but there is a strong trend to turn off the supposedly straight path into this phase of life beforehand by means of new building. Against this background, it is often a misconception to assume continuing to live in the newly built house. This was “generally” true when most still died in their first marriage at eighty years old – times change.
 

ypg

2020-07-21 17:01:52
  • #2
Forget it. I don't have to like it. But you wanted opinions... I don't see a questionnaire as a basis for discussion, so the angle of the bay window matches the angled side view... On top of that, a tilted house? The windows are 90s again.., or 80s?! And inside that would be way too boring for me. I don't see any consistent theme or style. Maybe this can serve as inspiration.
 

haydee

2020-07-21 18:59:03
  • #3
I would adopt the room layout similar to the Farmhouses.
 

maleba89

2020-08-03 19:41:08
  • #4
I have now adjusted the floor plan of the ground floor again with a wardrobe. I am currently still working on the upper floor but have now tried another approach to better orient the house towards the garden. What do you think?

The first two pictures show the new design and the last one the adjusted ground floor with wardrobe.

 

pagoni2020

2020-08-03 20:18:25
  • #5
I didn’t calculate it but it should be about 250sqm of living space on 2 floors plus garage+storage room there as well as almost 100sqm of terrace!!!
Your living room, on the other hand, has 24.88sqm, is framed by 3 closed walls and is therefore exactly the same size as your hallway!
Even with my amateur eyes I can see that you apparently still play Tetris, sorry-. Huge floor area and pushed together, built-in rooms, some of which are also dark.
With such a floor area, a skilled architect can plan a true paradise. Even your utility room is almost as big as the living room.
The bathroom upstairs is great. You can immediately tell who sat on the toilet because he surely has a kneecap fracture because someone else opened the door too hastily. That this spot for the toilet is probably the worst-place-ever doesn’t even require an architecture degree.
Also upstairs the hallway is one of the biggest rooms, plus bathroom and other rooms without windows, so with artificial light?? The master bedroom is next to the guest WC and is almost the smallest room in the whole huge house..??? Kid-2 wouldn’t be envied if they had that room, if they could even get through between the closet and bed.
You should enter exact real measurements of windows, doors, furniture etc. Despite already extensive criticism, you have apparently stayed true to your original, self-made path and picture 3 with the other version doesn’t make it any better. Here too the hallway is simply slapped in and is almost the largest room of all.
Don’t be mad at me but you plan such a huge house and obviously take over the planning yourself with a computer program? This surely does not come from an architect, who was mentioned at the beginning, or she wouldn’t deserve that title.
I really can’t understand it, almost 100sqm terrace and 24sqm living room with almost no windows and wherever I look I see hallways......
Just from the bathroom planning upstairs you should realize that a qualified professional needs to approach this plan idea.
I am truly no floor plan drawer but after so much of your effort since last time there is no improvement visible, that much I will already say.
 

hanse987

2020-08-03 21:07:06
  • #6
I do not find the drainage of the bathroom directly above the dining table particularly appealing.
 

Similar topics
06.04.2014Planning floor plan / first draft for first feedback32
18.06.2014Our floor plan design, your opinions20
30.06.2016Draft of the planner for our single-family house48
01.05.2015Draft - all directions in new construction of single-family house91
26.06.2015Floor plan question, stairs, window, orientation12
22.01.2016Kitchen planning with island and floor-to-ceiling windows12
11.02.2016Windows / Doors / Wardrobe13
12.09.2016Living room: How to arrange the sofa, TV, and cabinets?32
09.03.2017First draft of the floor plan for a 150m2 house31
31.01.2018Design living room / dining room. Looking for ideas10
16.06.2018The heating system does not fit into the utility room as planned27
09.01.20197.70m glass front living room house 11 by 11 meters14
08.05.2020Optimize OG Stadtville. Floor-to-ceiling window104
20.12.2020Smallest possible window for ventilation in utility room22
16.09.2024Building a terrace from formwork stones27
28.06.2021Placement of furniture in the living room in the floor plan10
31.05.2022Do radiators always have to be placed under the windows in new buildings?41
26.03.2024Renovate house from 1988 - windows and front door?15
26.05.2025Living room setup possibly through breakthrough expansion28

Oben