Single-family house - Opinions on our design

  • Erstellt am 2017-09-29 23:14:10

chand1986

2018-01-04 18:28:07
  • #1
I fully agree with kbt09's proposal.

Until then, messing around with old suggestions is exactly useless for you.

Therefore: Wait for the response from the community, then come back here with it and until then definitely do something good for your own nerves. If in doubt, simply: Nothing.

Because honestly, it sounds like you are mentally at your limit. Neither good for you nor for potential helpers.

And here in the thread there are people who can and will be helpful if you provide the information as requested above.
 

MBS2201

2018-01-04 21:07:16
  • #2
Hello, I will gather the information and restart the topic in a new thread.
Nevertheless, I still have some questions about it.
1. The drawing of the floor slab is available and the architect used it as a template for the house.
All KG pipes were installed as shown + additionally 2 connections in the ground floor pantry.
The only difference from the drawing is that the floor slab is 12.49x12.49m² in size.
The floor slab was inspected and approved as okay by the structural engineer (30 cm thick).

--> what is the drawing of the originally planned house needed for?
The house is to be built exactly on this floor slab. No demolition is planned.

Somehow I cannot imagine that you cannot place a floor plan on such a large floor slab + the numerous connections. The architect also created the design that you declared unsuccessful because of the room layout.
It should be possible, for example with a different room layout, different stairs, both levels the same size, etc.

We would like to start in spring and the construction company is now pushing slowly because otherwise they will accept another contract and we could then possibly only start from the 4th quarter. I want to avoid double burdening as much as possible.
 

kbt09

2018-01-04 21:16:54
  • #3
Please read the entire thread again.

There are still open questions like the passage between garage/house. Recently, dissatisfaction with the ground floor has been expressed. Although you have often written that you incorporated our thoughts, we have had little understanding of that... see bedroom arrangement, etc. Then always the staircase being in the middle but on the other hand you criticize the brightness of the stairwell. And so on, so really go through everything once and put it together in a structured way. That also helps you gain clarity. Anything you want to explain to others in writing, you have to have already thought through yourself enough to be able to formulate it briefly and concisely. And if you can't do that, it's an indication that you still have uncertainty yourself.

And therefore a restart, where you also present your collected thoughts, would simply be better.

Is the garage floor slab already in place? Is the superstructure of the cistern drain okay?

------------
And, has the architect you parted ways with ever given price estimates?
 

chand1986

2018-01-04 21:19:31
  • #4


You are misunderstanding the forum members here. It is possible. It is also intended to be done. Only your architect's performance so far has been deemed insufficient.

To make better suggestions, the helpers need the requested information.

The task (assistance) of the forum is to help you—with enough information(!)—to get to a better suggestion, which a professional (architect) then refines into a building plan.
 

11ant

2018-01-04 21:36:47
  • #5
We can follow you so far. However, I consider it pointless not to discuss the "old" design at least "alongside" everything that can be developed "from the foundation slab" in terms of floor plan ideas. Perhaps it is a great starting point, and even the chemistry with its planner fits (?)

I also maintain that you should investigate the circumstances of the sale. If the previous builder is going through a divorce, fine. But if the reason is that a basically correct foundation slab unfortunately is at the wrong height or all pipes come out correctly but the insulation underneath was forgotten or something like that, then get rid of the thing. You seem to have somehow hopelessly fallen in love with this foundation slab. Being a builder is not only an emotional thing but also a matter of common sense.
 

MBS2201

2018-01-04 21:47:27
  • #6
The foundation slab was inspected by an energy consultant at the time of construction. Reinforcement and insulation are present. I have seen photos. Additionally, the accuracy was checked again by a structural engineer and the documents were reviewed. (used materials, insulation, reinforcement, etc.) I only received the information "personal reasons" for the sale from the previous owner. If the slab has been deemed okay by two independent experts, I see no reason to have it torn down.
 

Similar topics
14.09.2012House financing - house, garage, and foundation slab approx. 290,000 EUR11
13.11.2013Initial Draft Floor Plan - Opinions Welcome21
06.05.2015Draft single-family house with garage/carport - please provide evaluation22
27.08.20152 full floors, passage to garage, utility room under stairs25
11.09.2015Building a garage on the boundary is not possible according to the architect.11
11.09.2016Base plate - construction/insulation etc. - experiences please!10
13.09.2016Insulation under the floor slab EPS or XPS?12
21.11.2016Misplanning Bavaria - slope towards house and garage - instead of away23
27.11.2016Double insulation below and above the floor slab?10
02.09.2017Build over gas, water, electricity, and telephone lines with a garage?13
26.02.2018Insulation under reinforced concrete floor slab KFW5520
07.11.2018Cutting the floor slab due to incorrectly placed drainage pipes20
01.07.2019KFW 55 - Insulation under the floor slab37
02.02.2020Insulation under the floor slab - Is it sensible? Experiences39
27.12.2021Base plate pedestal height measurement17
04.04.2022House Construction 2.0 - First Floor Plan Draft155
22.09.2022Basement without additional flooring / cleaning floor slab34
31.12.2022Is the base plate properly sized?20
20.11.2024Floor plan EFH165 sqm first draft - Architect dissatisfied74
29.04.2025Insulation of the ground slab in the basement with thermal stone12

Oben