Newly built city villa with a granny flat and double garage

... sorry, you seem to have time for blah blah. As I wrote right at the beginning, this is a comprehensive project where you can’t just move a wall to cleverly fix inconsistencies, poor layout or similar issues.

I found, for example, very pleasant.

The highlight, however, is your adapted bathroom



Where exactly is the bathtub freely accessible? At the end beside the shower.

You apparently have not yet addressed my comments regarding the staircase, staircase location, and my doubts about the width of the WC niche or the fitting of the stair cutouts, etc. In this context .. the ground floor bathroom

with the planned corner entry and cabinet is also not such a highlight for a new build.

I still believe that you have to start this project from scratch, mainly because the living room will become so dark. Because the terrace of the granny flat lies in the boundary strip and for various other reasons listed here by everyone.
For example, I am missing the street layout on the site plan:


Is there also a street on the right side of the plan? ... Then also an indication of how the neighboring houses with their garages are roughly positioned, so that one can distance oneself from the current plan.

I did address the points and also provided explanations for them. I can also plan from scratch here, but it wouldn’t help because there simply is no sign of "experienced" input here. As I said, taking a schematic layout without scale, photographing it on paper, or tediously switching it on, making a PDF out of it and uploading it here is far less work than continuing to address my plan here, which from your perspective is "nonsense" and that should be a piece of cake for an "experienced" person.

It is simply a pity that apparently the core problem is not being addressed here (I am certainly receptive and deal with the "meaningful" criticism (for example, can you still see a standing toilet anywhere???), otherwise, like many others here, I simply wouldn’t respond anymore). I think I have received my stamp...

I have addressed the points and also provided explanations. I could also plan anew from scratch here, but it wouldn't bring anything, since there is simply no sign of "experienced" being shown here. As I said, schematic arrangement without scale on paper to

+draw and to

so many people have told you here what they don't like about the floor plan and also why. you have an architect at hand and if we and you see that nothing more can be made out of the current floor plan, you can also tell your architect (and that’s what he’s paid for) to please start again from scratch. sometimes unfortunately it's not enough just to move a few walls. but it is not our task to create a floor plan for you from scratch, we don’t know you and the property well enough for that. we can only point out the issues that WE consider impractical. if it then becomes clear from the existing floor plan that no satisfactory solution can be achieved, a completely different idea has to be considered, maybe a different staircase design, a different house shape as kbt09 already suggested, etc.

First of all, I apologize for being off-topic.

Rarely have I had so much fun in this forum – a big thank you to everyone involved, this thread is really top-notch. Unfortunately, my popcorn is now all gone.

And now seriously:

Hardly any forum has ever impressed me as much as this one, especially in this topic, regarding the patience, helpfulness, and above all the equanimity of the participants.

That brings us to the actual topic: dear google80, what exactly are your expectations of an internet forum?

Just for the record:

YOU asked here for help and suggestions regarding your draft. Subsequently, several competent people apparently took the time to deal with your project. Voluntarily and free of charge!

Even I, as a layman, can see that your planning contains serious flaws. This "improved" bathroom, for example, is almost the most ridiculous thing I have ever seen. Sorry – it’s just like that.

Many attempts have been made here to help you and a whole range of critical points have been pointed out to you. You can implement such suggestions or not.

What simply does not work in the context of a forum like this towards voluntary helpers is to respond to constructive criticism totally uncomprehending, dismissive, know-it-all, and snappy. Again: You asked for help! If you do not want/cannot accept criticism anyway, why post here at all?

By the way, hardly anyone here will be able to "quickly draw" a new plan for you – after all, that is no walk in the park. For no one. That’s why there is the professional group of architects…

Finally, three sincerely meant pieces of advice to the OP:

1) Have the floor plan newly designed by a good architect. As it is, you can somehow live in it. But it could certainly be much better.

2) Reconsider the granny flat. As it is, it is neither fish nor fowl.

3) Unfortunately, once again personally: learn to distinguish criticism of the matter from personal criticism. Nobody here is interested in attacking anyone as a person, not even you.

With that in mind,

best regards from Cologne

Here I pass you my popcorn [emoji897]

Greetings

Somehow it's a pity about all the energy and time spent by all forum members. Here someone is completely resistant to advice and at the same time extremely sensitive. How is any other result supposed to arise? But at least the thread is good for entertainment

Just a completely different question: why were you with 2 architects?