Indigenous model - is this still legal?

  • Erstellt am 2018-06-12 11:55:44

Maria16

2019-05-16 08:45:24
  • #1
Then subsidies just won't be given anymore. Bravo, €1200 per sqm for everyone in a "hick town" where it takes an hour to get to the city during rush hour and there isn't even an S-Bahn connection. Would she prefer that? And now please don't start again with the argument that you would just have to designate enough building land for prices to drop again. You have consistently ignored the point that the infrastructure around it (daycare, kindergarten, schools, doctors, etc.) then almost has to be conjured up by the municipality.

By the way, it was your free choice from the beginning to choose a different education.
 

face26

2019-05-16 08:58:34
  • #2


I don’t want to claim that it’s perfect, especially since every municipality handles it differently. In our area, there actually was a points system where points were awarded for local residency but also for number of children, workplace, club membership, parents’ place of residence, and so on.

Local residents don’t have any right at all... otherwise every local resident could say "I want one of those"... but they are preferentially considered during allocation. Why is that? We’ve touched on it here several times already, but here are a few more points:

A municipality is, on the one hand, the body that represents the interests of its members (or at least should). Basically, it should be in the interest of the municipality to act sustainably and with a future orientation. That means ensuring that the municipality continues to exist in the long term and provides its members with a good living and working environment.
Therefore, a municipality must take into account both the interests of the settled economy as well as those of the (private) residents. If a municipality wants to remain viable in the long term, it must maintain a balance.
For example, aging of the municipality must be avoided (we all know about dying villages, and the age structure "Christmas tree" which nowadays looks more like a kebab). Smart municipalities take action for this, such as expanding daycares, and giving stronger consideration to families when allocating building plots.
In the same way, homogeneity should be considered, which is why smart municipalities will ensure there are forward-looking concepts like multigenerational houses and so on.
It would also be very wise not to force the children and grandchildren of older residents to move away, which later on causes organizational problems with care needs, but rather to try to enable children and grandchildren to continue living in the municipality.
I don’t want to question your potential engagement in clubs in the new hometown, but in the majority of cases, participation in clubs is usually higher among locals than among newcomers. Exceptions prove the rule.
I could go on giving more reasons here.

Again, I’m not claiming that exclusive consideration of locals is right. But in my opinion, preferential consideration is quite understandable from the municipality’s point of view.
I don’t deny that it’s not always fair, but there will never be a perfect solution.

And again... you have options, you yourself said so... you’re just not willing to pay €300/sqm... well, then buy a condominium, a semi-detached house, or something else. There are options. But don’t say you have no options.
 

Camille1984

2019-05-16 08:58:38
  • #3
Conclusion: Stupid and your own fault for caring about the education of our children (in my case the particularly disadvantaged). Soon there will be no social professions left because no one is allowed to be that stupid. You already have no doctors in rural areas and no teachers or educators in the cities. And if no one wants to do these jobs anymore because despite long and good training they can't afford anything, then there will be no daycare places and even more hours will be canceled at school. Then none of you will be able to work in your great jobs anymore either or you just can't afford anything because the nannies are ripping you off... If the middle class can only afford life in a limited way because a few percent still want more, then things will get very interesting in our country. Or the construction prices will go down again.
 

face26

2019-05-16 09:02:43
  • #4


Now don’t make a fool of yourself. You sound like a sulky child who isn’t allowed to have what it wants.

We are not talking about Munich or Stuttgart city. There I would agree with you. It just isn’t enough for what you imagine.
 

Camille1984

2019-05-16 09:05:34
  • #5
I am ending this for myself right here now. The locals feel justified and threatened by the newcomers, and the newcomers feel disadvantaged. Maybe through previous commitment it will succeed for me that my family might be worth it after all (child, social and used profession in the area, club involvement, etc.), that I am worthy of eventually receiving something that corresponds to MY ideas of price and building possibilities.
 

Camille1984

2019-05-16 09:06:49
  • #6


But in certain communities it would be enough! That’s what it’s about!
 
Oben