Floor plan of a 200m2 house, your assessment?

  • Erstellt am 2022-08-12 11:48:52

Nemesis

2022-08-16 15:43:01
  • #1


Is the question serious? You have a budget of 600k and here you present an architect's design that can cost almost twice as much. The assumption that you did not do it exactly like that is therefore obvious. Despite your detailed answers, it is still not clear where this is supposed to lead. The objection that downsizing is not so easy is correct and important. It will then no longer be this concept, this style, just smaller. It will be a completely different style, a completely new concept, something completely different. Unfortunately, "just" saving 50-100k but keeping the building structure as is won’t work; you would have to save 300-500k. You have left many questions unanswered; it is noticeable that you did not expect this budget overrun, not to that extent. So shake yourself off and start over, with a clear budget. Or increase it and build this great house exactly as is. In my opinion, there will be no middle ground.
 

ypg

2022-08-16 15:46:38
  • #2


Hmm, no experience, but that would not be allowed at all in the residential construction sector here in Germany (which includes single-family houses), or would be contrary to any contemporary energy regulation with a U-value of 2.x. Austria is probably no different in this regard. At least that is my current knowledge.
Or is there already something new with better values? Do you know anything? Do you have a manufacturer? I personally know that the material is very weather-sensitive. It is rough in itself, and algae quickly settle on it.
 

face26

2022-08-16 15:53:20
  • #3


What makes me suspect that? Your statements here in the forum.

Maybe I am reading it wrong or you are expressing yourself awkwardly?

What you presented in post #1 is a draft. Whether you call it a preliminary draft or not doesn't matter. You stated a budget for it. Then you were repeatedly told that the budget and (preliminary) draft don't match. Not even with more buffer. Then you want to adjust/shrink the draft to also become cheaper. Later you wrote that you want to follow Plan A and only pursue Plan B if that is too expensive. The latter sounds like you first get offers in and if it's too expensive, you replan.

If you told your architect the 600k budget for the house and that draft came out of it, then the architect is not good. Not in what she designs (I think the draft is great) but in no way fitting for you because simply too expensive. Why I don't find it good from a design point of view, I've already written - downsizing doesn't work in house construction in my opinion.

One more substantive thing. The style you like (which I also happen to like) is in 99% of cases very expensive. You think these clean lines are not costly because with exposed concrete screed you save on the covering etc. But usually it’s the opposite. There are fewer companies that offer this because processing is often significantly more complex. Special treatments necessary (sanding, sealing, etc.) and that makes it expensive. Same goes for concrete stairs.
 

driver55

2022-08-16 16:38:04
  • #4
That’s exactly what I already said, “Once through the grinder”… You could almost say, “Reset button, here I come.”
 

Sunny_OE

2022-08-16 17:59:23
  • #5
I have read/heard different things, what you wrote, but also that polycarbonate has meanwhile reached very good values, is more shatterproof, lighter, and much cheaper than glass, and is very suitable for, for example, light strips. It could possibly also be an option for me as a railing. I also know many very aesthetic examples where it was used in museums, etc., but also in residential construction. But I would have liked to hear practical experiences.
 

SaniererNRW123

2022-08-16 18:43:15
  • #6

Yes, you can achieve U-values below 0.80. Yes, it is suitable for skylights. No, not for regular windows, because you always have frosted glass and cannot see through it. Cheaper? I don’t think so, because you have to contact specialized companies, which are more active in industrial and commercial construction. I don’t know of any manufacturer/producer for regular residential construction.
 

Similar topics
13.11.2013Initial Draft Floor Plan - Opinions Welcome21
09.02.2014Bungalow Floor Plan Draft Opinions22
25.02.2014Single-family house floor plan design23
06.04.2014Planning floor plan / first draft for first feedback32
18.06.2014Our floor plan design, your opinions20
30.06.2016Draft of the planner for our single-family house48
30.01.2015Building with GU - Offer from GU including design22
11.03.2015Ideas for single-family house design with basement47
01.05.2015Draft - all directions in new construction of single-family house91
06.05.2015Draft single-family house with garage/carport - please provide evaluation22
22.07.2015Draft floor plan bungalow - Your opinions please!14
03.08.2015Floor plan draft city villa feedback13
30.04.2016Planning our single-family house - What do you think about the design?56
19.10.2016Single-family house as a terraced middle house on a slope - design18
30.05.2017First draft single-family house 150m² with basement38
07.11.2016Floor plan design city villa with double garage38
07.07.2017House design - Single-family home - Can be separated into a two-family home in the future72
06.02.20171. Draft floor plan single-family house 150 sqm50
09.03.2017First draft of the floor plan for a 150m2 house31
13.06.2017First draft floor plan single-family house (approx. 200 sqm) - Please provide feedback46

Oben