Floor plan planning single-family house 180m2 south access - chaotic floor plans

Yep, we basically had to start from scratch because the [Einliegerwohnung] was added. What information do you need about the original site? It is very flat. How do you like the floor plan?

How do you like the floor plan?

Not the one of the upper floor at all, but the one of the basement three times (?)

Regarding the [Einliegerwohnung] ... I wouldn't want to live there permanently ... It faces west and has the [Lichthof]. It will be quite a dark apartment, especially in winter.

Here are the attachments again. No idea why it didn't work properly earlier.

Phew, that is quite a transformation… I confess: I am not just not a fan, but an enemy of access paths between cars. It’s not just about the mail and parcel carriers who have to squeeze between vehicles, but also the residents themselves when they don’t use a car.

An accessory apartment without a terrace… how old is the mother-in-law? Does she pay for the basement, in return she gets a dark hole in the basement without a terrace, but has to accept quite a long walk around the house? Almost no daylight comes through the window of the accessory apartment due to its location. And what does come in doesn’t reach the middle of the room. An accessory apartment in the “basement” is better placed on the south side. The idea with the access on the west basically takes away your entire west garden. You barely have a meter left to walk around the house there. You should think about how you want to walk through, use, maintain, and make accessible your outdoor areas. I don’t see any practicality for everyday life.

I also find the location of the technical room quite illogical: why accept the long cable run when you could use the front corner of the house for the technical room? Spontaneously, I would put both the technical room and the accessory apartment at the front. Do you know what the planner was thinking that one has to cover an eternally long path around the house for the accessory apartment?

It must be quite an evil mother-in-law to be parked as a basement kid in a catacomb with access through the light well. The architect seems to have a fondness for hose rooms overall – at least not much residential architecture in mind. I currently don’t have the time to look up the thread, but we once had a case here where the OP had to share the planner of a multi-story apartment building because the developer, in addition to one or more multi-family houses, also built, if I remember correctly, a single-family and a semi-detached house. I don’t really find anything s*xy here.

I also find the technical room quite illogical in terms of location: why accept the long piping when you could use the front corner of the house for the cold storage?

I can only agree with the question. Where does the long pause actually come from: did you have little time, or did the planner take ages for this stroke of genius?