General criticism of architecture, spatial layout, exterior appearance

  • Erstellt am 2018-11-29 13:55:37

ypg

2018-12-02 10:27:59
  • #1


I liked the first alternative better. I missed some quotes but picked up fragments. So for me, the fact that the windows are lowered to 75 cm parapet height means accepting a strut for that. Why? So the desk height is the same. But then you can’t open the window. The safety bars would also bother me; they would be annoying inside, and outside they don’t look good. The seating window on the ground floor is squeezed in. The floor-to-ceiling window in the living room is directly blocked by the sofa. A storage room without a window works. But not this door under the stairs. By the way: the last draft is not the best. Is there a setback now toward the terrace on the ground floor or not?

Upper floor. Having one rather large bedroom instead of two small ones is a matter of taste or depends on whether it works for two, that the other is not disturbed. However, I don’t see any proper closet planning here, just arbitrarily placed wardrobes. And it is even said that storage space behind them should be created. The bedroom will be cluttered! The bathroom is very large. I would reconsider this: a more thoughtfully designed bedroom, a smaller, cozier bathroom, and a storage room, maybe even the necessary work corner, would definitely fit here if you make an effort. Because if you plan the dressing room and bedroom small, you get by with about 17 or 18 sqm. You have 26 there, but an unplanned room.

Otherwise: children’s wishes, office, an elitist parents’ area in terms of size: you will have to make compromises in functionality here. You could leave everything downstairs as it is; a sink in the kids’ bathroom does not create more washing area anyway, I don’t know where the special laundry is dried, probably in the office... somehow everything will work, somehow. I would also initially leave the aquarium aside.
 

Christian K.

2018-12-02 16:25:35
  • #2

Thanks. For your information, our development plan also only allows 2 full floors. If the third floor has a maximum of 75% of the footprint of the floor below, it counts as a recessed floor and may be built. If we built a gable roof over the second floor, the house would have a similar exterior shape.

I love secret doors etc. So you get into the pantry and the technical room through a cabinet door. That is done more often in kitchens and my brother-in-law is a carpenter and can make it for us in the hallway for the technical room. So we have a cabinet wall with a wardrobe etc. and behind the outermost door you get into the technical room.

Yes, that is true. We are currently trying several things here and have already said goodbye to that version. Yesterday we were at a kitchen studio and worked out some ideas. Either we want more hallway or more kitchen. If we want more hallway, the cabinets could be shortened from 60cm to 40cm and the island also from 120cm to 110cm. See drawing. As said, these are considerations. The 40cm worktop could be used for the kettle, coffee machine etc. The cooktop and sink would then be on the island. Perhaps we will leave the wall standing and thus have a bigger kitchen, then the island can remain 120cm and the cabinets 60cm wide.


Our requirement was that there should be room in the master bedroom for a 250 cm and 300 cm wide closet, as well as a 200 cm highboard. We want to place the closets against the wall so no labyrinth will form, but theoretically you could place the 300 cm closet away from the wall if you want to create an additional "room" behind it.

There is no bathroom design yet. The drawn furniture is only examples to show, e.g., that there is space for a double sink. We only want one sink etc. The bathroom design upstairs is still to come. The upper floor will probably be like that. The upper floor was tricky anyway. The stairs, the development plan, and our requirements do not make it easy.

Definitely

More light? Currently, almost 5 m of windows are planned in total. Yes, the windows are not floor-to-ceiling, but since light comes from above, a wider window provides more light than a tall window. Sure, a floor-to-ceiling window would be nice, but then we wouldn’t have any walls left at all.
Lawnmower, garden furniture etc. are things for the garden and therefore go into the garden shed.

We do have to adhere to the development plan. Setting the stairs back is therefore not possible. The door to the utility room does work as it is because the access is not via the stairs but there is already a door opening at the front door. The place where you drew the door is not possible because of the riser shaft. Under the stairs is only an additional storage room.
If we move the wall in, we can also get an island in, just 110 cm instead of 120 cm and the cabinets in the [-wall will only be 40 cm and not 60 cm. If at all, we want the aquarium in a prominent place and not in the office, where only my wife is, for example. That way the rest of the family can enjoy it. Another advantage is that the aquarium is not exposed to direct sunlight, which is good. Although it is not in a very quiet spot, we don’t have many alternatives. Whether the aquarium will actually happen is another matter. We want to have one, but the one drawn costs around 10k. Certainly nothing that will happen in the next few years.

What bothers you about a direct bedroom access from the bathroom? We had at times thought about an open bathroom. If it’s the sound, there are doors that solve that. My parents, friends, etc. have bathrooms that are not directly connected to the bedroom, but the bedroom door is always open, but yeah, mine has no direct access.
The toilet can also be rotated 90°. We haven’t decided yet. But either way, why would one hit one’s knees? If someone is sitting on it, the door is locked. And if it is not locked, one can quickly call “door closed” before being seen.

Attached is the S-shape with 75cm sill height. The graphics show the location of the house on the plot. 5 m to the front street. 3.40 m on the carport side and 3 m on the other side.


 

Christian K.

2018-12-02 16:36:35
  • #3
We are aware of that, but we don't want to wall up the wall. It also didn't look particularly good from the outside. But now I just have an idea...
?
The floor layout is not optimal, we know that, so we are open to suggestions here. Constraint: the staircase must remain and at least two wardrobes (250cm and 300cm) must be accommodated. Optionally the 200cm highboard.
 

montessalet

2018-12-02 17:38:19
  • #4
That looks clearly the best visually. I like it very much.
 

ypg

2018-12-02 18:57:35
  • #5

I wouldn't do that. 60cm cabinets are definitely more valuable. Besides, you can also fit kitchen appliances in there. I would rather reduce the island from 120/110. 90 is also cool. You can clean it quickly from one side as well.



That would be fiddly...



Yes, but other things usually no longer fit afterward. There will definitely hardly be any more "laundry space" - one or two washbasins here or there.



And what about seasonal wardrobes? Decoration stuff? Tools, ironing board, etc.? Ok, you still have a storage room upstairs... calculate if that will be enough.
The pantry is still there as well. But it would also not be sufficient for the ironing board and cleaning supplies, as waste paper and old glass already take up a lot of space.



Unfortunately, we don't know it. So why is moving the stairs not possible?



How about you upload the plot plan, i.e. the site plan here? So far, only distorted 3D drawings can be seen....
 

kaho674

2018-12-02 21:13:03
  • #6
Development plan...

I suspect a 3m boundary directly adjacent. But the stairs could possibly protrude as a subordinate component? But anyway, OP has no interest.
 

Similar topics
26.06.2015Floor plan question, stairs, window, orientation12
09.09.2016Bedroom design35
22.02.2016Size of the bedroom and children's room38
12.07.2016Floor plan question, garage, stairs33
15.08.2016Technical room as small as possible - under the stairs?10
13.10.2016Extra bathroom from the bedroom or storage room after all?29
02.02.20178.02m positioning sink / toilet69
21.11.2018Switch for roller shutters on the window or on the door?38
06.11.2017City villa floor plan / window arrangement, feedback desired16
02.02.2018Bathroom planning - How to utilize space for washbasins and cabinets32
09.01.2018Exhaust air in the bedroom - supply air in the storage room24
14.03.2019City villa with approx. 200 sqm - without basement. Please provide feedback50
19.05.2018Floor plan of new single-family house: Are window/door/interior wall size/arrangement okay?20
05.02.2019No underfloor heating in the bedroom?22
07.06.2019Pretext in the bathroom on the upper floor directly next to the window17
08.07.2019Bungalow 135 sqm: Floor plan + windows104
08.05.2020Optimize OG Stadtville. Floor-to-ceiling window104
15.08.2020Cupboard under the stairs or small storage room11
22.09.2021Floor plan of bedroom, dressing room, and en suite bathroom36
29.11.2021Window sill height 130 in the bedroom / study?93

Oben