How much additional cost according to the structural engineer's calculation?

  • Erstellt am 2023-06-11 11:17:12

Lauralila88

2023-06-18 14:42:56
  • #1


Hello,

sorry that I always reply briefly but I am mostly stressed and unfortunately know nothing about the topic of building. I actually trusted the company but the trust is slowly fading because the situation turned out worse than expected.... namely I talked to the construction manager and he said that we are building in earthquake zone 3 and need a white tank, meaning a concrete basement, and that we are not allowed to build any other basement. The stupid thing is the soil report was created as part of the planning work and we did not know beforehand that we have "difficult soil". Additional costs are now about 30,000 euros! And of course we have an architect, who is included in the house price with 8,000 euros, but he could not have known this without the soil report either.

Why we decided on H&H is because we wanted to build stone on stone. We looked at the Massa House show house and then agreed that it should not be a prefabricated house—besides, it would have been significantly more expensive just like the offer from Heinz von Heiden.

I would like to start my own thread with our project but for that I need to get familiar with this place first.

Why should the architect have known beforehand that the soil was difficult?? Without a soil report he wouldn’t know that. Indeed, he requested a soil report but by then the contract with the housebuilding company was already signed.

Best regards
 

xMisterDx

2023-06-18 14:58:55
  • #2
That the house is in earthquake zone 3, even you could have known, the architect must know it.

Leave out the basement. This will not be the last occasion where you will lose money.
 

WilderSueden

2023-06-18 15:04:05
  • #3
Didn't you have a list of requirements for the fixed price? I remember that the nationwide providers gave us such lists stating which wind, snow load, and earthquake zone are prerequisites.
 

xMisterDx

2023-06-18 16:18:10
  • #4
Is almost certainly stated in the contract. The general contractor would be crazy not to delimit themselves accordingly.
 

11ant

2023-06-18 19:53:40
  • #5
Indirectly, you have at least confirmed that besides this strange provider, you only know Gabriele’s favorite Heinz and a self-build provider – which is dangerously little for someone who signs expensive contracts. You still haven’t answered my question whether the basement is also required because of the hillside location (because I didn’t ask it in DaF???).



Eight grand is a lot of money just for a """architect""" (mind you, in triple quotes) who more or less just draws a floor plan into the site plan, with views and a section, but just pictures, WITHOUT the actual basis. That the service phase 1 is listed first was not made up by some joker. With a proper architect contract, such carelessness would be a case for the architect’s professional liability insurance. So what about your right of withdrawal, you can’t keep pulling that off forever! Now quickly go to the lawyer, I already told you who in my post #40!


In the same post, I also linked you the questionnaire; you can fill it out even without prior learning success.
 

mr.xyz1

2023-06-18 20:50:45
  • #6
We paid 9k net for a "real" architect up to the execution planning stage, just for orientation!
 

Similar topics
16.12.2013Pre-planning with the architect - is having your own floor plan sensible?18
27.05.2015Does an external chimney have to go down to the basement?12
04.08.2019New build bargain house from Poland, what to consider?10
17.10.2019Costs of soil assessment / geotechnical investigations34
17.10.2017Construction costs for a single-family house 190m² + basement including a granny flat28
16.02.2018Stress with the architect - naively signed the preliminary contract17
04.11.2018Single-family house with granny flat - Which company to build with?18
03.11.2019House contract Massa Haus GmbH from Simmern - Preparation10
20.06.2020House construction - Massa Haus GmbH or alternative?10
15.07.2020Soil survey even if I don't build a basement?13
09.06.2021House construction planning: solid house or prefabricated house? With or without a basement?80
22.02.2023Soil report for bungalow 140 sqm, additional costs for WU concrete?33
10.10.2023Special floor plan or boring with basement?20
29.01.2024Basement made of WU concrete or Poroton?17

Oben