House design with SweetHome3D - Thank you for your feedback

  • Erstellt am 2017-02-25 10:53:10

11ant

2017-02-25 14:41:34
  • #1


Yes, go ahead. Nothing makes a plan more understandable than its "story" (in both the poetic sense and the historical one).

Maybe you could also post a drawing of the house you have lived in so far, with explanations of what you liked about it.

P.S.: "the world is a village" - I just noticed, there are two people from Forchheim in the thread.
 

Treppauf

2017-02-25 14:44:55
  • #2
Does not fit. The pictures really look like "doodles" and are supposed to serve as a basis for building a house? The whole thing looks more like playing with building blocks or one in the sandbox. Sorry, unfortunately not suitable as a basis for discussion.
 

He.Di

2017-02-25 14:47:31
  • #3


Lighting through the bathroom, or through the utility room, I have also considered. Maybe something else will come to mind. You would really have to completely change the plan. Well, the greenhouse, yes. That’s true too. It will certainly be built much later than the house and everything is very rural there... meaning that maybe no one will even notice if the greenhouse is a meter too far...

Hm, yes, the design may be somewhat childishly naive, but it is just for us. Whether it can ever be sold is actually pretty irrelevant to me. But that is always a thing. We only recently sold our farmhouse in the northeast. Everyone said: it will take years. Even the realtor was skeptical. After a week online, it was gone. From that perspective...

But in any case, it’s good to read something positive once in a while. I have put some THOUGHT into the house as well. Surely not everything turned out well.
 

stefanc84

2017-02-25 14:52:07
  • #4
I think a one-level house with so many rooms is not feasible. I also once saw a bungalow floor plan from a prefabricated house manufacturer – there were only small chambers, so the professionals didn’t do much better. It’s just not really my thing. Especially if you build a bungalow to live barrier-free, it seems like you’re creating additional barriers in that regard (many corners, narrow passages). I’d rather have a stairlift to the upper floor.
 

Nordlys

2017-02-25 15:11:34
  • #5
No guys, the modern mantra, open, large rooms, few doors, it's not a dogma. There are also conservative people who, for example, want the kitchen to just be a kitchen and the living room a living room, with a wall in between, and meals are eaten in the kitchen. And coffee is drunk. And drawing with the grandchild. and so on. These are simply different attitudes towards life. And the hallway or foyer is also closed. You don't want a stranger to look straight into the living room when someone opens the door. Because a stranger can be a guest or an enemy. (smile) So, dividing the areas into real rooms and not just zones appeals to me as well. Nevertheless... it has to be possible to do it differently. The stairs need to be different, the kitchen wing moved to the front, the guest toilet next to the entrance, the bedrooms away from the street side towards the back....
 

He.Di

2017-02-25 16:33:09
  • #6


Alright then.

We have already lived in quite a few houses... currently on 70m2 under the roof as an interim solution. Everyone has their own room there. There is no bedroom and no living room. Bathroom and kitchen are shared. I'd say it's somewhat like a shared flat. A few months ago we sold our farmhouse in Western Pomerania. Built in 1840. 200m2 of living space plus an attic used as a studio. And as old houses usually are... the rooms were quite unconventionally arranged. The old folks didn’t always know exactly what they were building. The kitchen was to the north, for example. We don’t like that at all. My sleeping room was 9m2. More than enough for me. But I don’t have a bed. I sleep on a futon on the floor. We now know: 77m2 is just a bit too small and 200m2 is way too big. And we know: 25m2 for a living room is plenty (if it’s just a living room and nothing else. Living means: hanging out together, listening to music, watching TV). We both want our own bedrooms, call them chambers, and if one cooks and the other lounges in the living room, then the one doesn’t want to hear the other’s clattering pots, and the food should smell good in the kitchen and the incense stick in the living room. Both at once is less good. We both need our retreat spaces because we are not professionally employed in the sense of working away from home but spend most of our time together at home. And if my wife plays piano downstairs in the hallway, I can calmly do something upstairs in the studio. Not the other way around, I don’t play piano.



And that has very little to do with being conservative. It is exclusively about personal experiences and preferences. If someone wants to offend me, they call me, or us, conservative. I simply refuse to go along with any nonsense just because it’s currently trendy. THAT would indeed be conservative. I’ve also lived in completely open apartments and found it totally impractical. And yes, it’s true, I don’t want someone who rings the doorbell to immediately see the whole house and I find a dirt lock and a vestibule extremely practical. That’s where shoes and coats belong. The planned vestibule is big enough for all shoes. Even a wardrobe for all my wife’s shoes fits in there. And that means something. If I want, I can also work a lot with glass and create airiness inside the house. If I want.

I designed the kitchen like this because I thought eating there would have a kind of conservatory feeling, being surrounded by glass on two sides.

Tell me, why does the kitchen have to be at the front and where should the stairs go? I drew the guest toilet there because I thought it would be better to have all sanitary facilities together. Kitchen, utility room/technical room/bathroom/toilet all on one side seemed sensible to me.

Although the house is surrounded by two streets, there is almost no traffic. Very few residents, no through traffic. Like I said: rural. That’s why my wife’s bedroom faces east (morning sun?), because the street is not disturbing. By the way, I find it interesting that everyone here criticizes the room sizes. I’d be curious how big your children’s rooms are? One “chamber” is over 9m2 in size and has an additional dressing room of over 4m2, meaning no closet is necessary. Just a bed. Or rather a futon. Nothing more.

So tell me, how big are your children’s rooms and what do you do in your 50m2 living rooms, and have you ever gotten upset trying to watch the news while your wife absolutely had to unload the dishwasher?



We agree on this: It’s not YOUR thing. In your opinion, bungalows shouldn’t exist. You surely don’t mean the stair lift seriously. For example, my parents are 81. They are both fit, can still climb stairs but it’s tiring and they don’t want to do it every day anymore. But they would never in their life get on a stair lift, not if it’s possible otherwise. Understandable, right? But they don’t need one anyway, since they live on one level... with just as many rooms.



Thanks for that extremely productive and valuable contribution. That helps me incredibly. Of course, I play with building blocks in the sandbox. I’m an artist. I’m allowed to do that. No need to apologize. But I accept it.

So.

And thanks to those who really have something to say: for example, pointing out the lousy guest toilet or the convoluted bathroom access. I can do something with that. And if some find the chambers too small for their needs, okay. I will think about it. But I also tried to explain the “why.”
 

Similar topics
06.05.2015Living/Dining/Kitchen: How do you live or how will you live?52
15.09.2014Floor plan bungalow 160 sqm - Your assessments?15
15.02.2015Dressing Room/Bedroom Problem - Floor Plan Discussion25
03.06.2015Floor plan planning: Bungalow ~130m²58
20.01.2021Bungalow floor plan - What should be considered?164
09.02.2018Floor plan for a 150 sqm single-family house with a living room facing north21
05.11.2017Floor plan of an accessible bungalow229
20.10.2017Floor plan bungalow 150m² - Opinions wanted30
02.08.2018Floor plan of a bungalow approx. 150m² - What do you think about it?23
04.12.2018Toilet window in the guest WC next to the entrance door - is it now a no-go?44
06.06.2019Ideas and opinions on Bungalow 131 floor plan requested19
30.08.2020Bungalow floor plan 150 sqm, closed kitchen, covered terrace40
10.11.2019Finalization of floor plan bungalow 130m² for 4 persons199
15.01.2020Bungalow 148m² site planning / floor plan planning280
06.01.2021Floor plan of new construction bungalow 100 sqm46
26.01.2021Floor plan design bungalow 130/140 sqm24
02.04.2021Floor plan improvement ideas?31
03.02.2022Floor plan bungalow approx. 135m² Your opinions?45
15.12.2022Planning guest WC in new construction - How big should it be? (DIN?)107
17.02.2025Floor plan of a bungalow with 140 sqm - does the storage space fit?175

Oben