Urban villa floor plan, single-family house new construction opinions

I have also created an alternative plan. In this one, we avoid the pipe-shaped rooms.

Any opinions on this?

Any opinions on this?

This is a bit better (judged purely visually without the measurements). But close only counts in horseshoes. The parent area just doesn't work like that.

In your latest version, the hallway has become dark again.

The "bedroom" is way too small. You practically have to squeeze yourself through to the bed. I would also generally reconsider the staircase. Half-turned is personally a compromise for me that you make to save space. A landing staircase would definitely be nicer.

Regarding the ground floor: To be honest, I don’t quite understand your enthusiasm for it. You have an unused open space above the kitchen. The table is too close to the fireplace (alternatively too close to the kitchen). The living room is also very awkward (sofa not facing the TV and standing in front of the window). Plus the already discussed problem with the pantry.

My suggestion: you have so many requirements for the upper floor, so just plan that first, without any thoughts about the ground floor. Give yourself the freedom to move the staircase as it suits the upper floor. You have nothing to lose in this experiment.

My suggestion: you have so many requirements for the upper floor, so first just plan that, completely without thinking about the ground floor. Give yourself the freedom to move the stairs as it suits the upper floor. You have nothing to lose with this experiment.

That's how I will do it once...! :) Planning doesn’t cost anything

What do you think of my current draft?

Well, "it couldn't be worse" is after all just a silly saying and basically doesn't deserve anything else but to have the opposite proved ;-)

But I think you can at least be flexible in the planning phase.

Whatever that is supposed to mean (?) I had suggested starting with the upper floor. By that I did NOT mean dividing the areas of the upper floor resulting under these unfavorable conditions on the basis of the requirements from the ground floor in the least painful way possible. RATHER: to arrange and format the rooms of the upper floor. But you did not plan the upper floor first, you only drew it first. That is something completely different! Between writing and sending it was just rephrased as follows:

My suggestion: you have so many requirements for the upper floor, so just plan that first, without any thoughts about the ground floor. Give yourself the freedom to move the stairs as it suits the upper floor. You have nothing to lose in this experiment.

That’s exactly what I meant: see what happens if you don’t put this ridiculous stair position, around which the whole house twists, under monument protection.

Always draw the furniture to scale. Your drawn bed is max. 1.8m wide. How should the rear support look dimensionally? Are you allowed to do that? Could you please sketch that? Play around a bit with the basic shape. No one is forcing you into a square. Your ground floor will not be sun-drenched.