ONeill
2016-05-28 11:33:42
- #1
Think also. We have received offers between 1750 and 2700 for these services (NRW).
Opinion on the house design
- Erstellt am 2016-05-20 00:30:54
reeneex
2016-05-28 16:01:38
- #2
So, here are now the latest proposals taking into account the boundaries to be observed, etc.
kbt09
2016-05-28 17:18:00
- #3
... Sorry, but this is not the further development of the construction company planning, but of your planning. The dimensions are a plague.
And, a staircase with 13 risers will never fit there.
The children's room is still a dark hole. I would like to see the bedroom realistically furnished. The purpose of the slanted wall in the dining room is not clear to me, except that it creates a bottleneck there (only about 235 cm passage .. how is a table supposed to stand there?).
The living room could also be placed in the lowest basement corner with the windows. What is the purpose of the thick masonry block there?
You can no longer separate the basement as a granny flat. And how to furnish the office is also not clear to me. Why is the storage room in the basement not accessible from outside? (Lawn mower, etc.)
Why only 1 garage? And which boundaries need to be observed? Maybe set it once (belongs to the site plan).
Take another look at my sketch .. I would be interested to know what you don’t like about it.
Comparison ground floor:
to 
Comparison basement:
to 
-------------------
And a small hint ... such a forum lives from engaging in DIALOGUE and not just
writing and that’s it ...
And, a staircase with 13 risers will never fit there.
The children's room is still a dark hole. I would like to see the bedroom realistically furnished. The purpose of the slanted wall in the dining room is not clear to me, except that it creates a bottleneck there (only about 235 cm passage .. how is a table supposed to stand there?).
The living room could also be placed in the lowest basement corner with the windows. What is the purpose of the thick masonry block there?
You can no longer separate the basement as a granny flat. And how to furnish the office is also not clear to me. Why is the storage room in the basement not accessible from outside? (Lawn mower, etc.)
Why only 1 garage? And which boundaries need to be observed? Maybe set it once (belongs to the site plan).
Take another look at my sketch .. I would be interested to know what you don’t like about it.
Comparison ground floor:
Comparison basement:
-------------------
And a small hint ... such a forum lives from engaging in DIALOGUE and not just
so, here are the latest ideas taking into account the boundaries to be respected, etc.
writing and that’s it ...
tomtom79
2016-05-28 17:23:28
- #4
@kbt
Just let him, maybe he likes routes that he pays dearly for
There is a world of difference between the two drafts, if he is farsighted he knows which one is better.
Just let him, maybe he likes routes that he pays dearly for
There is a world of difference between the two drafts, if he is farsighted he knows which one is better.
reeneex
2016-05-28 19:33:59
- #5
So the first draft didn’t work because of the distances to the property boundary. There must be a 3m distance, that’s why the garage is separate. The terrace is now realized as a balcony. The dimensions come from the program, I can’t do anything about that. The architect’s design is still to come. The slanted wall is intended as a placeholder for a breakfast bar. The software inserted the stairs like this. It should fit. The children’s room has a window and will get daylight lamps. The wall block is a placeholder for an "optical" fireplace. The storage room can still get a separate entrance. I’m very happy about your comments and opinions and will address them if possible. Here I have now tried to present a further development. with your program it looks much better, what do you use? 
kbt09
2016-05-28 22:00:16
- #6
I use VA Professional
But, honestly, you plan with minimal distances .. just look at your path "optical chimney" (what is that?) and sofa or table (120x80?) and MAIN path to the kitchen. Counter and then a cooking island? Size? Distances? Why two seats right next to the table at a strange counter?
Bed .. the room is 320 cm deep, passage to the dressing room about 80 cm and then you want to place a bed for 2 people against a 240 cm wall (in the last version the wall was still 211 cm) ? What kind of bed is that supposed to be?
WC and washbasin .. much too small, no pre-walls taken into account, etc.
And, what happened to the granny flat?
---------------------------
STAIRS .. my little hobby ... by the way, a program just inserts stairs. You have to set the parameters for that and also have some knowledge about stairs
The basement should also have a room height of about 250 cm - right? That makes a floor height of about 280 cm. With 13 steps that results in a rise of more than 21.5 cm. You have now moved the door to the children's room again, probably so that a wardrobe (which probably must not be deeper than 60 cm) fits better. But the previous stair space of max. 312 cm has shrunk again. Because you can’t enter the children’s room over the stair opening
In my profile I have explicitly stated:
Step size= 2x rise + 1x run - IDEAL: 63 cm
Comfort= run - rise - IDEAL: 12 cm
Safety= run + rise - IDEAL: 46 cm
In your case, before moving the children's room door:
Step size= 2x21.5 + 1x 25 = 68 cm versus IDEAL: 63 cm
Comfort= run = 25 - rise 21.5 = 4.5 versus IDEAL: 12 cm
Safety= run 25 + rise 21.5 = 46.5 versus IDEAL: 46 cm
So the stairs are safe but neither comfortable nor easy to climb.
-------------------------
Normally, garages should be allowed to be built on the property boundary. Or is it because of the basement below the garage?
Well, whatever ... but I would still be very interested to know what you don’t like about .
But, honestly, you plan with minimal distances .. just look at your path "optical chimney" (what is that?) and sofa or table (120x80?) and MAIN path to the kitchen. Counter and then a cooking island? Size? Distances? Why two seats right next to the table at a strange counter?
Bed .. the room is 320 cm deep, passage to the dressing room about 80 cm and then you want to place a bed for 2 people against a 240 cm wall (in the last version the wall was still 211 cm) ? What kind of bed is that supposed to be?
WC and washbasin .. much too small, no pre-walls taken into account, etc.
And, what happened to the granny flat?
---------------------------
STAIRS .. my little hobby ... by the way, a program just inserts stairs. You have to set the parameters for that and also have some knowledge about stairs
The basement should also have a room height of about 250 cm - right? That makes a floor height of about 280 cm. With 13 steps that results in a rise of more than 21.5 cm. You have now moved the door to the children's room again, probably so that a wardrobe (which probably must not be deeper than 60 cm) fits better. But the previous stair space of max. 312 cm has shrunk again. Because you can’t enter the children’s room over the stair opening
In my profile I have explicitly stated:
Step size= 2x rise + 1x run - IDEAL: 63 cm
Comfort= run - rise - IDEAL: 12 cm
Safety= run + rise - IDEAL: 46 cm
In your case, before moving the children's room door:
Step size= 2x21.5 + 1x 25 = 68 cm versus IDEAL: 63 cm
Comfort= run = 25 - rise 21.5 = 4.5 versus IDEAL: 12 cm
Safety= run 25 + rise 21.5 = 46.5 versus IDEAL: 46 cm
So the stairs are safe but neither comfortable nor easy to climb.
-------------------------
Normally, garages should be allowed to be built on the property boundary. Or is it because of the basement below the garage?
Well, whatever ... but I would still be very interested to know what you don’t like about .