Open all-in-one room (about 52 sqm) and we never wanted it any other way. Sofa and armchair are around the corner. The table and the kitchen are our central place. I hate it when dishes and stuff are left standing around after cooking for a long time. For me, it's even the case that the kitchen is already completely clean when the food is just being placed on the table, all without stress and hectic I like to chat with friends and so while cooking and don't want to have to say "I'm going to the kitchen now, would someone like to come with me so I'm not standing there alone?". I also find it strange that some think it should not smell like food when I cook elaborate meals for friends. It may smell and have a fragrance!
I don't understand the arguments against separation here, because in a 30 sqm kitchen I can do all that too, only that I/others could additionally go to another room for more quiet/less smells/more cozy light etc. And from the cooking island you don’t talk while frying, bubbling and with the extractor hood on to the people 10m further away on the couch anymore.... Especially not when it’s around the corner. Here a partition makes no big difference, without extending walking distances.
My kitchen is tidy either way, so that wouldn’t be an argument for separation. But for example, after eating you can change rooms and no longer enjoy your drink/evening in cooking smells. I also can’t imagine having everything cleaned up with elaborate dishes. At least I need more than just a pot and a pan that fit into the dishwasher for that. And I don’t want to just pile everything on the plate and then wash immediately...
Furthermore, but that depends on the person, I would miss walls and storage space. That way I have two more for cupboards/sideboard/dresser etc. At least in our place there are toys in the kitchen and living room at the moment, which I don’t want to constantly carry up and down. But I also have a large office on the ground floor, which is still so full of work stuff, paperwork, PC, printer/copier etc that there is no storage space for the kids, but not everyone has that.