Opinions on our house concept

  • Erstellt am 2019-04-17 14:36:56

Deliverer

2019-04-18 11:14:22
  • #1


Well, but: Almost.

And that’s the point. An efficiency of 1 (or even worse in the end) is the problem. Although of course the electricity prices in AT (thanks to hydropower, I assume) already shift the calculation with the 15 cents...

What I can’t really imagine is that it’s comfortable. I sweat at the forehead, but my knees under the table are trembling?!

But that’s just a guess. I’ve only tried it on a small scale...
 

Lumpi_LE

2019-04-18 11:18:37
  • #2
We were once in an Elk prefab house. Air-to-air heat pump and ceiling IR panels everywhere. That was terribly uncomfortable...
 

ypg

2019-04-18 11:29:01
  • #3
I always find this type of houses very impressive, even though I myself wouldn’t want to live in such a rather cool house. Why cool? Too many corners and edges. According to my Feng Shui feeling, that just doesn’t work at all.
But okay, everyone should build the way they like.


Cool... cool...



I think you have given a lot of thought to the "How do I want to live?"... "How can I implement what I want for myself and my family?"
But I think you started somewhere in the middle without a clear thread, found alternative possibilities on the internet without researching whether the techniques or design elements harmonize with each other, etc.
I am truly no expert regarding technology, but combining many systems is more complicated than a system that works with another system.
This also applies to the function or its implementation and the question "What do I want to achieve with it?"

Let’s just take these two quotes from you:





How old is the rule to waste as little energy as possible? What does every builder want nowadays and what has the government regulated? Exactly: energy consumption. So why make it so complicated for yourself and use for example an old rule that can no longer be implemented with today’s technology? Temporarily reheating a cooled-down room constantly uses more energy than heating a temperature constantly.
A very important element (though I don’t know if a mechanical engineer understands this) is the solar energy trapped through the windows in the rooms. You do have nice big windows, but because of the projections like in houses in South Africa, the sun can’t reach them. That means: no energy comes in, and it gets pitch dark in your living rooms. You’ll have to work well with artificial lighting during the day.

Topic function:

I don’t want to believe someone wants to put a house of over 200sqm and wants to bathe/relax/feel comfortable next to a running washing machine. Added to that is that laundry involves storage and separation of dirty clothes as well as storage and drying of the laundry. Not everything is dryer-suitable and must be hung on a line. Later it then has to wait for ironing day (where again, in the bathroom?). Are you aware of this process?

Garage use: afterwards, going to the freezer room, then to put the clothes in the narrow and too small hallway? Okay, I also read that the freezer room is supposed to store the wardrobe as well, but why not build a) a freezer room and b) a room for wardrobe and such? Why is the room already being mentally converted instead of properly planning? The same applies to the hobby room.
I find planning a hobby room very important. Unfortunately, it is already "full" of office stuff; why someone then wants to repurpose it as storage is beyond me. Why not have a separate storage room?

Why does it have to lead through there??? You can plan this better!!
Plan: freezer room with storage options and laundry*, hallway with storage options, wardrobe area and hobby room, and/or on the upper floor a laundry room with storage options.

About the floor plan:


That is tiny and uncomfortable. Furthermore, the children always have to pass through your living area.





Further:
In the bedroom, I miss a place for the bed. The children’s rooms seem disproportionately large to me.
The all-purpose room on the ground floor is a narrow long corridor. A dark corridor.
The windows on the east and west emphasize the length.
The hobby room does not have 15sqm, but 36sqm???
Upstairs and on the ground floor there is a lack of storage options.
The kitchen would be too open to the neighbor for me.



Then a roof terrace would probably not be possible!



Conventional construction (straight, square, good) plus slope with simple technical equipment already costs more...
In this respect, I have written way too much here for a castle in the air.
 

hampshire

2019-04-18 11:37:54
  • #4
Electricity prices in Germany are at the top together with Danish prices. In Austria, you get by on less than half on average.



Conclusion: just forget the 2,000€ per sqm. That applies to an economical construction method and not to special properties as you imagine them. The detailed solutions

The detail of the heavily overhanging upper floor is very complex in construction if you want to do without support pillars. With support pillars, the design loses much charm. Such a solution quickly costs six figures in surcharges.

What I don’t like is the "function follows form" approach. Inside, many things are impractical. The rooms somehow seem to have to fit into the exterior. Great design is "form follows function."
 

kaho674

2019-04-18 11:39:02
  • #5

That thought kept going through my mind the whole time while reading...
 

haydee

2019-04-18 11:51:50
  • #6
that is why I also wrote + costs for a more complex floor plan. I intentionally wrote the 2,000 euros. The budget is not enough for basement, ground floor, attic with gable roof on a slope.
 

Similar topics
13.11.2013Floor plan for a single-family house12
13.12.2013Floor plan single-family house city villa37
24.06.2014Opinion on floor plan of shifted shed roof single-family house - Attempt 213
05.06.2014Opinions and tips on our floor plan12
06.08.2014Do you find the floor plan of our city villa okay?46
12.09.2014Floor plan. Opinions, ideas and constructive critiques.24
03.06.2015Floor plan planning: Bungalow ~130m²58
12.06.2015Please provide your opinion on the floor plan12
24.06.2015Standard floor plan for city villa with 130 sqm25
17.07.2015180 sqm city villa - Request for critique on the floor plan39
10.11.2015Single-family house floor plan planned, we like the windows43
11.02.2016Windows / Doors / Wardrobe13
13.05.2016Questions about house construction - Tips from experienced builders21
05.01.2017Our floor plan is under discussion39
19.05.2018Floor plan of new single-family house: Are window/door/interior wall size/arrangement okay?20
08.07.2019Bungalow 135 sqm: Floor plan + windows104
04.11.2019City villa floor plan - suggestions for changes?192
08.03.2021Bungalow Floor Plan Opinions31
06.01.2022Floor plan design for a new single-family house - 610 sqm plot - opinions welcome50
25.04.2023Enlarging the hallway floor plan REH from 1921: Tips?27

Oben