Evaluation floor plan semi-detached house 150 sqm without basement

  • Erstellt am 2025-08-17 17:59:03

ypg

2025-08-17 21:08:33
  • #1
Guys, sent too early. I’ll continue with the file about the saddle roof.



If your semi-detached house is already in the construction phase, then - I think - not much can be done anymore. The main walls are up, even if only on paper.

The second office or the purpose doesn’t make sense to me. Apparently, there are no children yet. It is mentioned that one of the children’s rooms can first be used as an office. In my opinion, there is no need for a third option to make the dressing room into a kind of third office. It will only be flexible for you as either a dressing room or an office.
The utility room is absolutely necessary. To say it clearly: you hardly have any space for cleaning or tools, supplies, brooms and mops, bags and stuff like that.

I’m sending this quickly now, more to follow.
 

ypg

2025-08-17 21:33:12
  • #2
I now find the technical planning (by you?) less good. Basically, I find the house design nice and spacious. A nice starter home, where you might separate later if the children and parents need more or different things and look for something else. Houses keep up with the times, and these times see everything as smart: one is kept as small as possible in a rudimentary way, another spacious and not as fussy as older semi-detached houses. Hobbies are no longer indoors, and nothing is stored anymore either. Both have their reasons for existing. The kitchen appears open and bright. There is a place for a wardrobe, also a multipurpose room. What else do you actually want besides a very spacious living area? I won't say anything about the neat balcony. It’s not given as a gift. But it certainly makes an impression. I would never make the hallway larger and make the room only accessible from the living area. I would remove these two wall stubs in the wardrobe and kitchen and continue the built-in wardrobes in the hallway by 90 degrees, then run them another 90 degrees into the kitchen unit. About the bathroom: I am not a fan of forced T-shapes. Usually, you ruin the room with the additional walls. Possibly generate the shower in an L-shape. 11 sqm can also be enough for a children's room. However, you have to be aware that there isn’t simply any space for furniture. The bed is 80 cm wide? By comparison, the 22 sqm for the parents, whether with an office or dressing room, is already very decadent. At the latest with the second child and a schoolchild, you’ll be rotating. Then you squeeze yourselves with your double bed into one of the children's rooms. At least that is what I would plan for. Or try to move some walls now. By the way, an office space can also be well found with a laptop in a wall closet or on wheels under the stairs.
 

kbt09

2025-08-17 21:56:05
  • #3

I have to disagree there. If you really work from home, especially with a family, you should have at least a small extra office room. Phone calls, video conferences, but also focused work can be done much better in a closed-off area.

Living/Dining/Cooking accessible only from the living area is already one of the changes from ... but I would also omit the hallway door and follow your idea to continue with cabinets in green, possibly only at dresser height.



I would consider moving the wall between the guest WC and the utility room about 10 cm or so toward the guest WC and have the doors to both rooms open into the hallway. That creates more freedom of movement inside both rooms.


... but unfortunately not very large ;)
 

ma.brey

2025-08-17 22:11:30
  • #4


Thank you very much for your effort.

Sorry. I could have told you that a gable roof with an unheated attic is being built. Only the exact roof pitch etc. are not known to me.

You have understood everything so far correctly. Currently, there are no two children yet. The thought was that we would prepare everything by then and only use the second office as an office when it is really necessary. We had considered using the room as a storage room until then.

The planning with the technical room comes from the architect; we have not taken/had any influence on that (except for relocating the washing machines).

The only storage space for cleaning supplies and bulky goods (beverage crates, etc.) is the crawl storage and under the stairs, since it is a concrete staircase. Therefore, we did not consider this space as a workspace.

To what extent would you make changes to the walls in the upper floor?

In the end, this already helps me. Many of my worries are shared because some “problems,” like the insufficient storage space, were already known to me. So far, we have been able to introduce changes/wishes but are still considering whether this could be a permanently satisfying option or if we should rather look for something else. Only that is not so straightforward here in southern Germany.
 

ypg

2025-08-17 22:48:33
  • #5

Gladly, there isn’t just one optimum.
But about the offices: they do exist. Downstairs, first a kid’s room. It was about the backup-office variant. You just have to take a look. They are just options, directions in which one can think.

Yes, I thought about that too. The WC can be “significantly” smaller. However, I would probably indeed rather place the Hakle wall shelf there and set up the multi-room as a utility room: laundry, storage room, office alternative, printer, plant growing, electrical devices, sewing machine. Cabinet space behind the door and a multi-countertop, with washer and dryer underneath.

See above

Something like that.
I would probably do it like that and keep openness for myself.





The kitchen will hopefully gain then.

Yes, that’s exactly what I would NOT do.

Here just a quick & dirty for the upper floor – without balcony consideration.

 

ypg

2025-08-17 23:11:48
  • #6
I forgot: with my upstairs variant, the drain planned in the NW corner may or will be in the way. One could change this by swapping the WC and the technical room downstairs and planning the drain next to the multi-room. However, this is only possible if, according to the planner, it is still feasible because it slightly changes the wastewater planning.


I do not see, if one models cleverly and is flexible in mindset, that one should distance oneself from the house.
 

Similar topics
22.03.2013Floor plan evaluation single-family house18
08.01.2018Stairs in the hallway, the floor plan is actually already done :o(20
24.03.2016Floor Plan Comparison Aura and Signum10
15.05.2018Floor plan design for a hillside house with 5 children's rooms370
17.10.2017Single-family house approx. 150 sqm floor plan - How to plan the staircase?65
24.09.2018City villa with straight staircase, open modern design, 140m²18
05.01.2024Soundproofing children's room12
02.07.2018Stairs in the living room as a hype - Pros & Cons?26
04.12.2018Toilet window in the guest WC next to the entrance door - is it now a no-go?44
22.10.2019Floor plan design single-family house 150 sqm - tips for improvement?441
30.08.2019Floor plan design: Is the hallway on the ground floor wide enough?57
18.10.2019Single-family house - Captain's house - 150m² - New construction - Tips needed20
16.12.2021Which prefabricated house provider - prices, experiences?212
04.05.2022Single-family house – new construction project from day one - and the planning begins313
28.04.2020REH - Floor plan planning - Kitchen too small30
02.11.2020Floor plan single-family house, approx. 200 sqm - comments welcome81
07.01.2021Floor plan design of a city villa with double garage approx. 150m²34
25.11.2022Floor plan multigenerational house conversion old barn202
07.07.2024Floor plan single-family house 147m2 - opinions, criticism, suggestions for improvement?43
15.12.2022Planning guest WC in new construction - How big should it be? (DIN?)107

Oben