Assessment "Fixed Price" Detached Single-Family House (Solid)

  • Erstellt am 2021-05-07 06:32:54

JennySing

2021-05-20 18:05:37
  • #1

Thank you for your plans and ideas. They look good. The footprint is already somewhat larger than what we had previously imagined, but that’s logical if the basement is omitted.

I will try in the coming days to transfer the current plans into a planning program and then share them with you. However, due to time constraints (kids sick...), I can currently only do a little.

Regards
Jenny
 

11ant

2021-05-20 18:31:19
  • #2
Why transfer? - we also take screenshots (or photos of paper plans).
 

driver55

2021-05-20 19:51:05
  • #3


At first glance, I liked the floor plan, especially the kitchen (photo). However, upon closer inspection, there are some unsightly points here.

You already say it yourself here:



    [*]For a total of 168 sqm, I consider 36 sqm living/dining/cooking to be far too small (as an architect, I would neither offer nor approve that.)
    [*]The dining area is only 2.70 m x 3.5 m (to the passage, so effectively only 3 m), which is just 9.5 sqm (8.1 sqm)
    [*]The kitchen, on the other hand, takes up 11.4 sqm, living 15 sqm
    [*]The parents' wing with over 30 sqm could have been much smaller (with makeup/beauty corner, or what is that supposed to be?) --> office upstairs (or do customers come into the house?) --> 50 sqm living/dining/cooking
    [*]On the ground floor, no shower is needed, saving another 2 sqm --> living/dining/cooking 52 sqm
    [*]Interior staircase + attic stairs means: upper floor hallway will be dark
    [*]The 2 m lines are suboptimal in all rooms. Children's rooms maximum 2 m closet (+ custom-made for knee wall?)
    [LIST]
    [*]I know why I'm mentioning this. We have one side with a knee wall 1.70 m, dressing row measuring 3.30 m, ceiling height from 1.70 m to 2.60 m. Built-in closet over 3000 €. If we had raised the knee wall significantly and could have bought a normal closet, we probably would have saved another 1000 €...)

[*]2 m line in the bathroom directly above the washbasin (WB) (one time swinging the hairdryer up and you hit the ceiling,) I miss a DWB
[*]WC interior (dark + ventilation)
[*]“Long” paths from bathroom to dressing room; always through the bedroom
[*]....

Is this already final?

Is there KfW40(+)?, due to wall thickness 49.5
 

Baugrübchen

2021-05-20 22:13:53
  • #4


Thank you very much for your feedback. We are already building, which is why the points are final. For context/orientation, I am happy to address your comments. Everything is of course subjective :)

In the dining area there is a table with 4 chairs, so the 9 sqm are more than enough. The kitchen is somewhat larger (my personal luxury room), offering a lot of storage space thanks to the good planning at the kitchen studio. The living area with 15 sqm is the point where more could have been done, but ultimately it is the sofa corner with the TV. Apart from a lowboard, we have no living room furniture. It has been that way for the last 12 years and will remain so (short- and medium-term). If things change, we will probably have to be creative.



Let’s get to the upper floor. The office on the ground floor was a must that we defined. We both work about 40% of our time at home and still want to arrive after work and put the stuff directly away in the office. Five years with an office upstairs have shown that we don’t carry the bags upstairs, but put them in the hallway/in front of the stairs or somewhere else. Before I delude myself into thinking I can change my habits, I prefer to plan the house according to our needs.

The shower on the ground floor is necessary for us: 2 adults and currently 1 child in the morning routine —> saves time and gives the opportunity to leave dirt (work, mud excursion, beach sand) downstairs and not carry it through the house.

Hallway dark: Yes, but this is no problem for us. Same goes for the toilet. The bathroom door is pretty much open all day, allowing sufficient light to come in.

Master area: Once the dressing room (unnecessary luxury that I gladly grant my wife). The bay window space (without 2 m line) is reserved for the relaxation area after sauna (unnecessary luxury number 2)

—> don’t get me wrong: We of course wanted these luxuries, otherwise we wouldn’t have planned it that way.

Kids’ room: The wardrobe can stand on the inner wall without knee wall restrictions (this is also planned there).

Bathroom: The bathroom is in the bay window, there is no 2 m line there, ceiling height is at 2.26 m. Is DWB a double washbasin? I have never seen an enrichment in this invention. We stand three at the morning toothbrushing party at one and are happy with it :)

Dressing/Sleeping: We work in the same job and get up at the same time. If it is not like that, the other one lays out clothes in the morning. There have never been problems. The note is of course still sensible.



No, not at all. We have a primary energy demand of about 63 kWh.
 

JennySing

2021-06-26 17:36:52
  • #5
Hello everyone,

after several rounds with the architect, with the goal of reducing our original plan (see earlier in the thread: approx. 200 m² with basement, ground floor, upper floor, and penthouse level) to save costs, we now have a new plan that incorporates some of the discussed points. Therefore, I am getting back in touch:


    [*
      The penthouse has been completely removed
      [*]the hobby room has moved from the attic to the basement
      [*]the guest/workroom has moved from the attic to the ground floor
      [*]the guest/shower WC has moved from the attic to the ground floor and has replaced the WC there
      [*]The glass joint between the garage and the house has been removed
      [*]The roof terraces have been removed
      [*]The kitchen/dining/living area on the ground floor has been reduced by approx. 10 m² to somewhat compensate for the increased space requirement on the ground floor due to the guest/workroom and shower/WC
      [*]Overall, the floor plan has become somewhat larger
      [*]With the ground floor, the upper and basement floors have also become slightly larger in the floor plan. The idea was to do without bay windows or similar and avoid the additional effort for complex insulation at such points
      [*]The living area has been reduced from approx. 200 m² to 178 m².

    I have attached sketches.

    There are still a few open points to clarify. Especially regarding the height profile in the garden. But I think we are close to being able to forward this plan for a renewed calculation to the general contractor.

    Inside, there are currently two major issues where we are undecided:


      [*]whether we should have a window/light strip or a door to the garden in the kitchen on the upper side of the ground floor

        [*]Storage space and work surface should also be sufficient as is
        [*]Without a window, it might possibly be too dark?!
        [*]On the other hand, a window on the north side would probably only interfere with the arrangement of the kitchen furniture and make it look rather busy, and probably little light would come in from the side anyway. So the only argument would probably be the access to the garden?!

      [*]Direction of the staircase
      [LIST]
      [*]We tend to prefer if you can go upstairs directly from the entrance area. That would place the basement access in the middle of the building. Would there be a draft there, or should we perhaps plan a door? But a door at the stairs only makes sense if the stairs are closed off, and we definitely want to avoid a tunnel-like character for the stairs.
      [*]With the current direction of the stairs, the utility room in the basement is rather narrow. If the direction were reversed, the utility room could be L-shaped (I added this in blue on the plan). With the current direction, the utility room could perhaps also be designed L-shaped if the stair descent is quarter-turned so that you look to the left on the way down.



What do you think? Comments on the mentioned points but also more generally are welcome again. If the thread drifts too much into the planning direction and no longer fits here, it can of course be moved.

Thank you!

Best regards
Jenny


 

11ant

2021-06-26 20:02:25
  • #6
I don't see any picture of the pre-new planning condition (?)
 

Similar topics
12.05.2014Idea generation for floor plan of 120m2 single-family house12
18.01.2015Planning phase floor plan single-family house15
08.01.2018Stairs in the hallway, the floor plan is actually already done :o(20
26.05.2015Our floor plan... please help with optimization.33
30.09.2015Floor plan of a single-family house with basement19
11.12.2015Question about floor plan, especially stairs13
02.05.2016Staircase floor plan design, tread and stringer21
03.05.2017Floor plan of a single-family house with a basement13
02.01.2019Feedback on single-family house floor plan 200 m² city villa with hipped roof32
20.11.2019New single-family house floor plan 150 m²40
05.07.2020Floor plan single-family house approx. 200 sqm double garage basement32
05.11.2020Floor plan single-family house - Your assessment20
02.01.2021City villa floor plan 180m², basement, 3 children - Your opinions on this?51
23.04.2021Bungalow floor plan 160-170 sqm with basement175
22.11.2021Floor plan 165 m² with basement, your opinion?52
19.09.2021Feedback on the floor plan design 150 sqm51
04.12.2022Floor plan of a single-family house approx. 190 sqm with basement on millimeter paper78
02.10.2023Floor plan single-family house ~165m² plus basement165
10.10.2024Floor plan single-family house 2 full floors 195 sqm gable roof in Bavaria25
22.12.2024Floor plan of a single-family house with basement, 150 sqm, only single-story allowed115

Oben