New floor plan for single-family house - your opinions

  • Erstellt am 2016-11-09 22:55:29

Climbee

2016-11-10 09:06:27
  • #1
Personally, I would also prefer the living area to be on the ground floor, but I think that's really a matter of taste. I have a friend who loves sitting on her balcony, even though she has a garden... So if someone wants it that way, fine. However, I would at least plan a staircase from the balcony directly into the garden.

The entrance area is totally cramped; if this really comes from an architect, then that alone is a reason to doubt his qualifications, sorry. There are many doors, little rooms without any space for furniture, but how are you supposed to find space for four people when you all come home together? Or even with strollers? This needs to be re-planned, and if only the extended utility room is removed, i.e., directly from the garage into the hallway, with the utility room being rectangular.

Both bathrooms are personally too small for me; I like them a bit more spacious. But again, that's a matter of taste.

What is a total no-go, however, is the walk-in closet in the bedroom. There is no room for any wardrobes at all. If my poor eyesight does not deceive me, the depth at the bottom of the plan is calculated as 70cm INCLUDING the wall. So barely 60cm of actual inside measurement. A wardrobe is at least 60cm deep, and you don't nail it to the wall, so it stands a few cm away from the wall. On the other side, 49cm INCLUDING the wall is indicated. I do believe that you don't need two 60cm wardrobes because you can lay T-shirts, sweaters, etc., and I only need 60cm if I hang something on hangers, but this here is too tight! There's still plaster on the wall, and you need at least 40cm internal measurement to lay T-shirts, sweaters, etc. properly. In short: both sides of the walk-in closet are too small for a 60cm or 40cm (45cm would be better here) wardrobe! The window is now planned at 1m, so the distance between the wardrobes as it is now is probably less than 1m, and you inevitably block the window a bit. Well, you could install a narrower window, but still, there remains less than 1m space between both wardrobe sides. That is not very generous, and if the window stays like that, you can't even open it properly. Honestly, something like this simply must not happen to an architect!

What I also don't quite understand is the open space above the living area. Is a gallery planned there? Why then isn't there a staircase directly from the living area upstairs? That would make sense to me. As it looks now, it’s just open upwards and increases heating costs, nothing else. I find a gallery quite nice; there would also be the possibility here, but as I said, accessible from the living area. Up there, you could set up a library and create a cozy little nook for reading, for example. Or move the TV upstairs. But I see something about a cold room. And I have no idea how you are supposed to get up there. Is there some kind of retractable staircase planned? Then I would really skip the open space above the living area or build a real gallery (that is nice but expensive) and at least partially use the upstairs space and only separate off part of it as a cold room/storage. As it is now, it makes no sense to me at all.
 

Climbee

2016-11-10 09:07:33
  • #2


The children are supposed to move downstairs when they are older, then they will have their own area with a bathroom downstairs. That makes sense if you like it that way. As I said, I would prefer the living/dining/cooking area downstairs.
 

matte

2016-11-10 09:10:13
  • #3
I really don't want to impose anything just because that's how we do it, but the plot almost screams split-level with the terrain slope... ;)

You have about 45m² (!!!) of hallway space combined. That is insane and a complete waste of money. (At €1700/m² that makes a whopping €76,500)

Attached are my thoughts on how to proceed with a split-level approach:

For the exterior dimensions, I have stuck with your design for now, but this only serves as a rough idea since wall thicknesses are not taken into account. With a bit of adjusting, however, this shouldn't be a big problem.

E-1 as a partial basement
The airlock via the utility room from the garage is dropped; I don't know if this is really wanted.
In the current state, with the room width and door arrangement, it is anyway the next space waste, which should actually also be counted as part of the aforementioned 45m² hallway.

E0 with entrance, wardrobe + 2 offices (later children’s rooms?)

E1 with parents’ area + large eat-in kitchen
including a ground-level exit to the terrace in the garden

E2 with living room + children’s room
The living room could be connected to the kitchen/dining area by a gallery (like in our house :D)
If the structural conditions allow, a large south terrace could be built on top of the garage, which can then be accessed from the living room. At the same time, the terrace could be reached from the kitchen via an external staircase.

The preliminary draft will even help you out here ;)


 

Climbee

2016-11-10 09:23:23
  • #4
I like the split-level idea, but that would be a completely new building application and wouldn’t have much to do with the one that has already been submitted with the existing plans.

Since there is quite a bit of (justified) criticism of the design here, I would consider withdrawing the building application for the time being if I were you. As far as I know, that is more cost-effective than submitting a follow-up application due to major structural changes. (but I’m happy to be corrected by people who are more knowledgeable about this)
 

matte

2016-11-10 09:31:36
  • #5
I must admit that I had not read about the already submitted building application... But even I would think that over carefully again...
 

toxicmolotof

2016-11-10 10:37:40
  • #6
Was that really an independent architect or an employee of a [GU/GÜ] who was supposed to do the planning? Somehow that sounds like the latter....
 

Similar topics
08.01.2018Stairs in the hallway, the floor plan is actually already done :o(20
16.03.2015House entrance with hallway or without15
15.10.2015Kitchen planning with deep windows43
23.07.2015House without garage and basement? Attic expansion? Lipoma?85
26.06.2015Floor plan question, stairs, window, orientation12
27.08.20152 full floors, passage to garage, utility room under stairs25
30.12.2015Floor plan single-family house with garage, self-planning17
12.07.2016Floor plan question, garage, stairs33
18.10.2016Plan location of house & garage within building window *Pre-planning*129
13.06.2017First draft floor plan single-family house (approx. 200 sqm) - Please provide feedback46
09.02.2018Floor plan for a 150 sqm single-family house with a living room facing north21
02.07.2018Stairs in the living room as a hype - Pros & Cons?26
29.09.2020Access from the garage to the utility room49
20.12.2020Smallest possible window for ventilation in utility room22
04.06.2021Floor plan 170m2 - Laundry room too small? Suggestions for improvement?42
09.06.2021Housekeeping room room without window - is the ventilation system sufficient?26
05.11.2021Floor plan bungalow 150 sqm with garage79
06.04.2023Plan living area floor plan62
07.03.2024Floor plan of a single-family house 240 m² with a partially built-over garage96
14.10.2024Floor plan single-family house 136m² with garage & basement17

Oben