But aside from that:
Practical would be the parallelism (at least in approach) of the two work surfaces, so rather Var. 2.
I have found that it is good if you don't necessarily cook directly AT the dining table. Guests also like to get up, move around, and position themselves "on the other side where they don’t disturb," so then between the window and the island. This variant (i.e., Var. 1) would also have the advantage that when there are no guests, you can look into the garden.
I think the cube variant from is great. It’s also something different... I am slowly getting tired of the long massive islands. And the bigger they are, the more impractical they become. By the way, also a plus for Var. 1 or cube... You wouldn’t always have to go around the island cabinet.
But no matter what: I would always make sure that the stove is not interrupted from a corner to the sink, but can be reached quickly.