Well, I haven’t read something so absurd in a long time.
Of course, in the example Flair, you would enclose the staircase exactly as you have already enclosed your staircase. In the standard version, simply move the kitchen entrance a bit further upward in the plan, then in the event of separation you can simply put up a wall and really use the staircase as an access. With your idea of external accessibility, you would have to plan the property about 3 meters wider.
And of course, upstairs in the version with the additional room you can also plan an apartment door... just enlarge the exterior dimensions of the house as much as you planned your house. That creates plenty of additional space. And, by enlarging the Flair 152 from the current 10.5 x 8.75 to your 11 x 10.5, the office on the ground floor can also become large enough to directly turn into a bedroom in the event of separation. Then you don’t have to do anything in the living area. Etc. etc…
Such a proposal as a basis is just a basis that then needs to be developed further, where here and there one or the other wall may also need to be adjusted.
EDIT:
In your version using the washing machine in the utility room on the ground floor for the upper floor... carrying the laundry there via the exterior stairs? No... no.
I never wrote that it’s not possible, but that it is more difficult. In this case, probably a double door would come into play, which would then stand open all the time, which looks ugly and additionally restricts access to the staircase.
Yes, in this floor plan a door on the upper floor would be more sensible and possible, but with my spiral staircase it would not have made sense, since you would then also have to extend the railing all the way up to the ceiling.
I am aware that the property would become wider. If that is not possible, a spiral staircase or similar could also be considered, although it would be more difficult regarding moving furniture upstairs. Another idea is to have the garage partially adjacent to the south side of the house and then extend somewhat over the house. Then the staircase could run along the east side wall of the house. These are all things that could or would only have to be implemented with a real property.
Yes, that would also be conceivable, although the bathroom would then need to be somewhat larger as it should have a shower and ideally a cabinet. What would be less suitable in this case would be the positioning of the garage. As I said, I am a big fan of a roof terrace and there should also be a second apartment door.
Theoretically, you could also plan the garage without a roof terrace, plan the roof terrace above the garden terrace, and have a separate outside staircase as entrance to the upper floor, but here I see clear disadvantages such as extra costs, privacy, size…
I have indeed looked at such floor plans in advance and also built upon them, but there were always things that did not completely convince me, so I kept redesigning more and more.
Yes, in principle it’s of course not ideal with the laundry, but there are also many people who even take their laundry to a laundromat or who have to go many floors down to the cellar for laundry in a multi-family house. However, I would probably also plan a separate connection on the upper floor so that a washing machine could stand there.