Floor plan 165 sqm rural Bavaria opinions

Ps I still wouldn’t be against a complete redesign - sometimes something good comes out of it ;)

I tried Katja’s suggestion for the upper floor, but unfortunately it didn’t fit in two places, so I discarded it again ;/ Otherwise, I see it the way you described it, regarding the children’s rooms. Best regards

Observe a finished dimension of 70 cm. Plaster and co also need space.

It will just look like an endlessly long tube!

Note the 70 cm finished dimension. Plaster and co also need space.

The children's room windows still have plenty of room to be moved down :)

Sorry, our opinions differ here.
2m x 5.2m + gable full room height + sloping roof over the beds, I don’t consider that "impossible".

This has nothing to do with opinion: they are too narrow, too long in proportion. Your 2-meter line is an estimate, and your windows with a width of one meter probably couldn’t even have a lintel there.

Do your thing, but this dithering in the upper floor only leads to worsening improvements.
A rough redesign with a different building structure, namely somewhat deeper, can only bring advantages.

Sorry, but this cautious "it could be done better" doesn’t work anymore.
I’ve been saying it outright since 2019.
The approaches on the upper floor are okay, but if it doesn’t fit upstairs, then it doesn’t fit. You should have noticed that yourself when the utility room was still squeezed in up there.

I bet any bet that an architect would verbally tear apart your planning. Considering that you have been reading along here for quite some time, the floor plan is, to put it mildly, really .... At least on the upper floor.

On the ground floor, the position of the rooms is exactly as many propagate here.

Structure of an argumentation:

[*]1) Thesis (claim) [*]2) Support with arguments/examples [*]3) Conclusion, summarizing statements again.

I am grateful for further suggestions. Whether my planner will verbally tear the whole thing apart, I will see. Best regards