Restrictive development plan - is buying land worth it?

  • Erstellt am 2020-01-30 20:16:14

apokolok

2020-01-31 15:49:48
  • #1

I understand it to mean that the house is basically allowed 0.1 of the plot area, but only up to 1,100 sqm. Above that, the absolute limit of 110 sqm footprint applies.
However, if the plot is larger than 1,100 sqm, the floor area ratio 2 (i.e. ancillary facilities) is allowed to exceed the floor area ratio by exactly this factor.
That means that for a 1,500 sqm plot, in my understanding you may still build 40 sqm with ancillary facilities.
If you cover everything completely with gravel, that probably doesn’t count, but that will not be the solution either.
I suspect that only small weekend houses are supposed to be built there, and no 200 sqm residential houses for permanent use.
 

Escroda

2020-01-31 17:28:26
  • #2
Okay, I switched perspectives and read the provisions benevolently from the formulator’s point of view probably 100 times and found interpretations for the explanations so that no gross error exists. Two points of criticism remain: - In 2.2 terraces do not belong in the list for Floor Plan II. However, I also found an excuse for this: only freestanding terraces are meant, i.e. those that have a significant distance to the residential building. - "the feasible building floor area depending on the permissible floor area ratio" is not to be equated with Floor Area I, as the bracket wants to suggest. Since your plot is a bad example because it is exactly 1100m² in size, I choose a plot of 900m² as an example. Regarding 2.1: A residential building may have a maximum floor area of 110m² regardless of the plot size. A residential building on the example plot may have a maximum floor area of 900m²*0.1=90m². Since single-story is required and only full stories count, "the feasible building floor area depending on the permissible floor area ratio" amounts to 90m². Regarding 2.2: The floor area for driveways, ... (Floor Area II) may be 180m² in size, or even more in exceptional cases. So on "my" example plot fits a 9m*10m=90m² house with a 4m*5m=20m² adjoining terrace, a 3m*30m=90m² long driveway, a 6m*9m=54m² double garage, a 4m*8m=32m² pool and a 2m*2m=4m² tool shed. Floor Plan I: House + terrace = 90m² + 20m² = 110m² => permissible Floor Plan II: 90m² + 54m² + 32m² + 4m² = 180m² => permissible
 

ypg

2020-01-31 20:07:35
  • #3
2.1 implies single-story construction (floor area ratio 0.1) If they were weekend properties back then, the development plan makes sense. I think so. And I also find it okay. Actually, I always had the question on my lips while reading why you insist so much on 200sqm. It may be that you need it (then it's not your property), but maybe you also don't have a realistic view of room sizes. But well: even with 160sqm you should give up the property. Nature lovers and hermits will have their true joy on the properties.
 

Escroda

2020-02-01 09:31:53
  • #4
In 4 it even states explicitly: I don’t think so. The formulations are quite peculiar. I wouldn’t be surprised if the justification for the development plan disproves my interpretations. While searching for this, I came across a newspaper article stating that a norm control procedure is pending. So there are at least indications of possible illegality. Obviously, this has been disputed for over 10 years, so the development plan should speak clearly by now. A development plan is supposed to show citizens the possibilities of construction and not cause confusion with Kafkaesque formulations.
 

Nordlys

2020-02-01 09:45:40
  • #5
Escroda, but you and I and Meyer and Müller can just go to the local town hall and ask, what do you want, I only half understand that, tell me.....Man, only the speaker can be helped. Of course, much clearer usual sentences would be nicer. But 10% floor area, 1 floor, 110 max. is already quite precise.
 

Escroda

2020-02-01 10:05:58
  • #6
Yes, but statutes are written, after all. And if it's only about the property purchase at first, a local consultation appointment is already a big ask. Relative floor area, absolute ground area, percentage exceedance possibility of a ground area, which has to be derived from a relatively limited floor area, the undefined terraces, the bracketed additions (ground area I / II), is anything but precise. As if the ground area ratio/floor area ratio calculation were not complicated enough already, here one deviates from the requirements of the land use ordinance in an hardly comprehensible manner. Therefore, initially my suspicion - which has not yet been completely dispelled - that these formulations are not compliant with the land use ordinance. It's a pity that the justification is not available online; I would find that really interesting.
 

Similar topics
27.01.2016What does it mean: plot ratio 0.4, floor area ratio 1.2, floors II - II12
29.01.2018§19 Land Use Ordinance - Floor Area Ratio - Permissible Floor Area16
15.08.2018Basic floor area ratio / floor area ratio for plots without a development plan: How to calculate? Experiences?18
31.07.2019Site coverage ratio, permeable paving for outdoor facilities11
30.11.2019Neighborhood concerns regarding exemption from the floor area ratio31
03.02.2020Floor area ratio / plot ratio in the development plan of 196811
14.02.2020Floor Area Ratio in Land Parcel Division18
11.09.2020Stepped floor house 23x30m plot with floor area ratio 0.2525
26.03.2021Floor plan of a bungalow on already used land108
05.01.2021Is the floor space index adjustable against an additional payment?15
31.07.2021Floor plan design for a single-family house for 4 people on a 390 sqm plot57
23.05.2021Floor plan for a single-family house on a 1200 sqm plot10
30.05.2021Buy a house when the floor area ratio is exceeded?22
20.06.2021Floor plan of a single-family house approx. 200 sqm with basement - rear development20
23.06.2021Floor plan for a city villa with a gable roof 140 sqm72
18.02.2022Floor plan of a 1.5-story house with a captain's gable on nearly 200m²89
28.07.2021Utilize the plot ratio for new construction, build over the terrace21
03.05.2022Floor area ratio calculation when 2 parcels need to be combined19
20.10.2023Verification of compliance with the floor space index (floor space index) in the new development area11

Oben