Floor plans of a single-family house with a granny flat, 280 m2 on a pleasantly small 320 m2 plot

Can someone also say something about the ground floor

I think the basement apartment has (apart from the light, toilet and all the inconveniences) the nicer living area. I would actually build it myself just like in my sketch. Nicely separated living room, large kitchen and a table... it's just a bit out of place in a 2-room basement apartment... On the ground floor, where actually significantly more people live, everything is cramped and unpolished. But I had no spontaneous idea how it could be better.

… I and Katja already have… nothing comes in anyway.

That's why I didn't bother to write more, but just pushed some walls around a bit for my own amusement...

Can someone also say something about the ground floor and make a proposal to Katja?

May I ask why there is no proposal from the architect for a million project? With a bit of leisure and much more information, I would probably plan the whole thing completely anew. But you have already submitted, right?

Can someone also say something about the EG and make a proposal to Katja?

Please respond factually and in detail to #37 + #48, that would surely help the other participants and possibly boost their motivation again.

What about this KG proposal? Bathroom-bedroom are thus separated and we do not have a double hallway.

Legally according to the state building code it is a single-family house with a granny flat, so 2 residential units and 2 required parking spaces. Practically, 3 residential units are possible. If you do it officially, you will of course need an additional parking space later.

However, it may also be that your municipality has its own parking space regulation and more is required, or the development plan specifies something different. As far as I know, we are in BW, so it may also be that even fewer parking spaces are needed since there has been an alternative regulation since 2016. Therefore, don’t just look at the state building code, but the exact requirements for your property are decisive.

If there are 3 residential units, as far as I know, you fall into a different building class. Then you also have to take some additional measures that are not required with 2 residential units.

Will there also be visitor traffic in the club office? If yes, how does the barrier-free access look?

Our project is simply not an off-the-shelf one

And precisely for this reason, you should find a suitable architect for such a project who brings your wishes into a coherent concept. If the general contractor only employs drafting lackeys, they will implement every customer wish, even if it is pointless!

But from what I read in the last page, you still don’t really know what you want. This must be decided once and then develop the house according to the specifications. If these basics change, you often have to start over!

What about this KG proposal? Bathroom-bedroom is thus separated and we don't have a double hallway.

Definitely an improvement, I think. However, the recess in the living room is not nice. In my opinion, the chill area is too small in proportion to the rest and is disturbed by the entrance area. The walls are also too thin. And it is always good to draw in the sanitary fixtures so that you can see what fits in there. What is the kink in the heating room for and why does it have to be so huge? Please include the door. Especially since you are very tight with the outdoor facilities here.