so they could work, but only if the island is not 1.20m deep as drawn (so 2x60cm cabinets). if you only use 60cm cabinets at the front and reduced-depth cabinets at the back, you get up to 20cm more space around the island. in both versions, you have a total of 1.7-1.8m for the two traffic areas on the long sides. the distance on the working side should not be less than 1m (personally, I actually think 1.1m or 1.2m is better), which means that for the rest, with a 1.2m deep island, only 0.7-0.8m remains. that can just about work, but these are rough construction dimensions, so you can easily subtract another 5cm. you wouldn't really be able to access the cabinets on the back of the island like this (I wouldn't go below 0.9m here with normally deep cabinets). moreover, I consider the layout of Kitchen 2 to be rather impractical regarding the workflow (you have to walk a long way from the sink to the cooktop). recommend visiting a certain forum soon for the kitchen planning.