Continuation of construction despite the construction stop

  • Erstellt am 2016-09-27 10:01:04

Komposthaufen

2017-01-31 14:27:32
  • #1
In case of dispute, this is decided by a court.
 

laurooon

2017-01-31 14:28:48
  • #2
The last two statements sound contradictory to me. Does this mean that a once approved building application cannot be contested by dissatisfied neighbors?

Let's assume that I want to build a bay window that extends 1m beyond the building window. This was submitted as such, somehow paid for and approved, the building application was granted. Can then any Susi Schneckenschiss or Hans Jedermann from the neighborhood still take action against my bay window? Yes or no?
 

Bieber0815

2017-01-31 14:34:31
  • #3
I think that is the problem. The issued building permit is no guarantee that the construction is actually lawful. Example: Federal Court of Justice ruling from 10.2.2011, Az.: VII ZR 8/10.
 

laurooon

2017-01-31 14:35:52
  • #4
Okay, so no legal certainty through the building permit. Who has to bear the delay costs that may arise from the construction halt? The client?
 

ypg

2017-01-31 14:41:41
  • #5


To my knowledge, it works like this: the building authority checks everything before granting the approval.
If a point is debatable because there is an exception or an exceeding or something similar in the building application, then either the authority itself decides on it or seeks the opinion of those affected, e.g. the neighborhood, through their goodwill.
It can also happen that you are tasked with knocking on neighbors’ doors to get their consent.
Nothing is approved that could be subsequently complained about.
 

Nordlys

2017-01-31 14:41:54
  • #6
Citizen Authority: Case 1) I am the affected person: application-rejection-objection-possibly remedy- if not: lawsuit administrative court. I am not directly affected, but have an interest because indirectly affected: e.g. authority permits guesthouse in residential area, rental is excluded in the development plan, then: lawsuit against this approval. Consequence: possibly the judge orders an immediate stop of the guesthouse construction to protect rights or to prevent facts. Or: the building proceeds, I am right, then it must be examined afterwards how to deal with the guesthouse that was then created. (Possibly conversion into rental apartments?) In any case: an authority cannot order without question. The judiciary has the final word in case of doubt.
 

Similar topics
31.10.2008Is a building permit also required for a carport and equipment shed?13
15.02.2011Building permit application12
27.09.2018Cost of building permit in exemption procedure, new construction11
28.11.2024Neighbor's lawsuit against approved building permit46
16.01.2017No building permit as long as the land is not developed?10
20.08.2017Issuance of the building permit?24
04.08.2017Building application or building notification15
08.01.2018According to the law, the building permit is automatically granted if12
11.05.2018Construction application costs only 40 euros due to exemption application?27
21.06.2018What must be included in the building permit? Legal certainty?19
18.09.2018Immission protection concerns self-service gas station - building permit?20
24.10.2018Broker sells house without current building permit. Notary costs?25
28.08.2019Building permit for terrace roofing14
04.11.2019Is only part of the building permit enforceable? How long is the building permit valid?42
10.01.2020Construction loan without building permit possible?17
23.09.2020Child construction allowance with non-final building permit49
30.07.2021Is building without a building permit possible?26
17.11.2021Official liability building permit neighbor - keywords sought14
28.06.2024Building permit - is a lawyer useful?12

Oben