Your thoughts on our floor plan. Thank you for suggestions

  • Erstellt am 2018-05-27 12:11:08

Hecht1983

2018-05-27 21:18:44
  • #1
I just found the "questionnaire" during the floor plan planning and will fill it out tomorrow. If this topic has ended up in the wrong thread, it can be moved gladly. Thank you
 

11ant

2018-05-27 23:10:41
  • #2

Kind Gisela, not only Horst Schlämmer needs a Dornkaat for this house. It looks like an English or Dutch warehouse style from the 1980s.


For a family of five? – the joke quickly fizzles out, you’ll only do that three times in ten years. And in the jacuzzi of the wellness hotel, that is cheaper than the surcharge for the oversized tub.


That would give me pause and doesn’t seem to be the only indication that the resident family won’t recognize themselves in the finished house.


All in all, I feel the same way.


This kind of profile contracts the house by two meters more in width, here it comes across as exaggerated.
 

kaho674

2018-05-28 06:20:37
  • #3

Overall, it should also be said that the straight staircase is extremely dominant and unsuitable for your floor plan. It creates nothing but corridor-like rooms on the 1st floor, dark corners on the ground floor, and space problems in the entrance area—why would anyone put themselves through that? That is completely beyond me.

If you only need a storage place for toys, I can recommend a cupboard.
Otherwise, the living room will probably rather become the children’s trash corner if the play area is not intended to be there. You can still try to sugarcoat the corner or leave your kids there in the dark—but that doesn’t change the facts: in my opinion, the space is missing for the TV wall and kids prefer to play in the sunshine.


Oh, that is supposed to be a bathtub—I thought it was a shower. Honestly, the bathroom is actually ridiculous. Sure, it’s just the kids’ bathroom and compromises are made in such cases. But here, only the staircase is to blame for this awkwardness. Get rid of it!


Yes, the entrance area is simply ugly and small. You squeeze yourself into the door and have this annoying staircase in front of you that ruins the whole floor plan, then this pointless dark corridor (what is that supposed to be?—a labyrinth?) or the dark, creepy wardrobe.
You actually want to leave the house right away there—just get out of there as quickly as possible.


In the garage? Yes, it makes perfect sense to outsource the groceries into the garage instead of planning a proper floor plan with a pantry right away. That’s why so many do it.

No—seriously: the place will cost you a lot of money. Such compromises are nonsensical and totally unnecessary! Do you want a corridor-like bathroom or rather a decent size with light and space? Storage room / pantry on the ground floor—is possible without having to run all the way to the garage. Play area for the children? Of course—that also works in the sun. More generous entrance area with wardrobe?—that should be doable. All of this is possible, I am pretty sure. The straight staircase probably has to be sacrificed for this, but it is just in the way anyway. But please stop sugarcoating obvious weaknesses. Here you are fooling no one but yourself.
 

ypg

2018-05-28 09:01:14
  • #4
I think the ground floor will be too dark. The garage is on the sunny side and doesn't allow any windows. And then I also read that it's not needed but is used as a storage room. That can be solved better.
Consider where the sun sets in autumn/winter.

Also, I have the impression that somehow empty space could be eliminated in the middle.
At first, I didn't think the staircase was that bad, since the narrow room to the north can also be used (I would make a small office corner there), but the longer you look, the more you realize that it is what unnecessarily stretches the space quite a bit.
Nowadays, a basement should be more integrated into the planning. Will it be just a utility basement? Doesn't get an outside stair? Then think about what should go in the basement and what needs to go elsewhere (bicycles? mower? etc.)
Instead of a garage, I would make an open bar as a carport, which starts quite far forward...
But without the property, this is just a rough guess...

Regarding accessibility: it doesn't just apply to bathrooms, but also to hallways: in my opinion, the house is not suitable for that. Because then, for example, the hallway would have to be wider and the entrance area would need more space so that the wheelchair can actually get into the house [emoji848]
 

11ant

2018-05-28 17:11:04
  • #5

Spelling correction :-(
It should of course be "contracts."


Straight_staircases "require" somewhat wider houses (with windows on both eaves sides).


The extent of the inconsistencies is as high as if one had to consider a rocky slope or similar severe restrictions. It seems to me that some wishes have been incorporated here that were originally meant for a detached house in the heart of the area and are now being pressed into a semi-detached house.

Hence probably also the association with a developer house: polished up with a few trendy gimmicks, one should not be able to taste that it pinches at several points.
 

Similar topics
14.01.2013Opinions about the ground floor layout10
17.03.2014Opinions on floor plan for a single-family house approx. 160 sqm29
12.09.2014Floor plan. Opinions, ideas and constructive critiques.24
10.12.2014Floor plan, please provide tips and suggestions, single-family house 160m²20
08.01.2018Stairs in the hallway, the floor plan is actually already done :o(20
12.06.2016Single-family house floor plan (2nd draft)10
12.07.2016Floor plan question, garage, stairs33
18.10.2016Plan location of house & garage within building window *Pre-planning*129
05.04.2018Floor plan/Floor plan ideas single-family house 180m², 3 children's rooms46
19.04.2018Floor plan of a single-family house (approx. 170 sqm) with garage - hillside location35
17.12.2020City villa floor plan 160 sqm, without basement - Your opinions on that?167
20.09.2018Idea collection floor plan single-family house, open construction method43
06.09.2018Single-family house, approx. 140 m², 2 children's rooms - What do you think of the floor plan?67
26.09.2018Floor plan of a 140 m² single-family house with garage - Is the house orientation okay?18
11.01.2019City villa floor plan 150 m2 - Your opinion is requested :-)45
15.08.2020Cupboard under the stairs or small storage room11
22.11.2021Floor plan 165 m² with basement, your opinion?52
14.10.2021Floor plan single-family house with 2 full floors with approx. 185m² on 575m²11
17.07.2022Floor plan: Door planning living room + pantry17
20.01.2025Floor plan single-family house approx. 135 m³, floor plan. Garage, 1.5 stories, 4 persons11

Oben