Which property to buy? The agony of choice

So with such a decision I would test. Just rent a motorhome and sleep on the favored property. Then spend Sunday there. That already gives you a feeling. Sun, noises, neighbors, traffic, some strange things usually stand out.

You sleep very poorly on a water vein. You won’t get any wiser from looking at the property for half an hour.

I don't find the size of the plot so very important. Of course, it should be sufficiently large for the house and some garden. Whether the "some garden" piece is 150sqm or 200sqm is not that important for feeling comfortable. It depends on the garden design. A dull lawn area doesn’t give such a green and cozy feeling, no matter if it has 100 or 200sqm. Only with really large gardens does the area really come into its own. But for that, you need at least 800sqm of garden space. I myself even have only 42sqm of garden. Still green and cozy and a lot of work. ;)

..that is of course a matter of opinion. We, with three children, would prefer a somewhat larger garden, especially since my husband would like to grow vegetables in the garden. But basically, I agree with you – sometimes less is more :-)

Yes, 1517 also has the access in the north like 1518 – but with the green area as a neighbor.

Sorry, I hadn’t read that very carefully :-(

Yes!!!
Of course you may. You are roughly at 1.50-1.70 with the KS - with a 45-degree roof you are at 2 stories. However, it is not called a "city villa." But officially that doesn’t even exist anyway (just like "turnkey") ;)

You are of course right! I was not quite clear - we absolutely do not want sloping ceilings already on the 1st floor. Maybe a recessed story would be the solution here, but then the living space on the 1st floor will probably be too small in relation to the ground floor.

So with such a decision, I would test. Just rent a motorhome and sleep on the preferred plot. Then spend Sunday there. That way you get a feeling. Sun, noises, neighbors, traffic, any strange things usually stand out.

You sleep very poorly on a water vein. Looking at a plot for half an hour doesn’t make you any wiser either.

..a very interesting approach - we are in the construction area several times a week - also at different times of day (because of the sun etc.) Unfortunately, apart from construction traffic, no other traffic is to be observed - neighbors have not moved in yet either. Surprisingly - the first house that was completed is a "city villa":)

Maybe a staggered story would be the solution here, but then the living space on the 1st floor will probably be too small in relation to the ground floor.

With 3 children, you have a high space requirement - I would also plan a "real" 2-story house. I probably didn't read about the 3 children before/didn't remember.
But wouldn't a shed roof also be an option? With a ridge height of 4.70, you reach two stories on almost the entire floor area; a shed roof opening to the garden would be a possibility to build the children's rooms with a loft bed on the second floor. My choice would also be 1434 or 1425. Because: wind mostly comes from the west, so also noise ;)

I always say: you can get a nice house with parking spaces and so on on every orientation. In this respect, I would probably prefer a play street location for you. Otherwise, I also find the whole Bogenstrasse on the right side quite attractive. No plot is bad. And what one lot has, the other may not, but it has other advantages. Unfortunately, such queries often make many unmentioned locations look worse than they are.
Just make sure it’s not too small: you want a big house and garden for children as well as usable space...

Surprisingly - the first house that was completed is a "city villa":)

That is not surprising.