Select a building plot - Which one should it be?

That may have been a bit personal.

Bad style to get personal here. Don’t you have any arguments?

It was simply judged a little too condescendingly for me.

Arguments are in #15

However, without locally accessible infrastructure within walking distance.

Which then becomes problematic again. From a transport policy perspective, it is not particularly good if you have to take the car for every trip, even if it is an electric car charged with electricity from your own roof. Currently, public transport may not be so en vogue due to corona, but that must not lead to throwing the entire energy and mobility transition overboard. One also has to think ahead: when you need more help in old age, people have to get to you somehow, and not everyone will have a car.

Well, I find 650 sqm a dream. Where do you still find such large plots?

I would approach it differently: Usually, you know how much space you need. If it is only about living, and you plan very cleverly, that may work out. But if you want to carry out your (self-employed) activity there at the same time, then the space requirement increases. My house is the absolute minimum for my space needs. With 0.2/0.4, a plot should not be smaller than 1,200 square meters. I would not have built a house just for living alone, it would never be worthwhile. However, I also have very special spatial requirements (operation of a recording studio). In areas with a development plan, you also have to be careful; in some cases the exercise of a freelance profession is even prohibited, which I consider unconstitutional, by the way.

Ideally, a village center is best, as it is always a mixed-use area, and in the middle was the smithy. I would rather use something like that as a model for today's new development areas. That takes up more space but loosens things up significantly. Municipalities should stop letting homebuilders finance their budgets.

Why is the thread being hijacked again with an unnecessary discussion for the OP?

It is the essential characteristic of an internet forum that questions are taken as an occasion for discussions. Those who just want a simple answer should please obtain paid expert advice.

We have been looking for a plot of land for 6 years already. The demands are no longer that high. The house should be for two people with one child and a spacious office, as I work from home in the afternoons. The location and the connection are definitely convenient for us. Also, I ride my bike 15 km to work, in case anyone is worried about that.

Anyway, I now have a feeling regarding the selection of the building plots or confirmation that my choice is not entirely wrong. Thank you very much.

Do you think the plot with the narrow access road still allows for sensible development despite this? I had some concerns about that. Otherwise, we would prefer this one.

We have already been looking for a plot of land for 6 years. The expectations are no longer that high.

What exactly have you done in the six years to get a building plot? Didn't any opportunity arise anywhere to take over a plot with a dilapidated old building from elderly people? That’s probably how I would approach it if I were looking for something. And if I personally scoured the villages street by street by bicycle. That would of course not work through internet portals and real estate agents.

Pianist, you have absolutely no idea how tight the market for acceptable plots of land is in some areas of southern Germany. In the first year you still have demands and hopes, after that you desperately search through all channels and by all means.

So finally hold back with your overly clever "let them eat cake" comments.
The cake is a lie!

It's similar to if a Chinese person here were to write to a Berliner asking why you don’t wear protective masks? Just go to the supermarket and buy a pack of 50. Here in China absolutely no problem...

Pianist, you have absolutely no idea how tight the market is for acceptable plots of land in some areas of southern Germany. The first year you still have demands and hopes, after that you search desperately on all channels and by all means.

But if that is really the case, prices should be much higher. At 150 EUR, the need can't be that great yet. We had that price here 20 years ago... Are there actually people from the left-wing spectrum in southern Germany who tell you clearly to your face that living space does not belong in private hands? Here in Berlin, you really already feel like an evil big capitalist. People already accuse you of single-family houses consuming far too much space. They are probably only satisfied when everyone lives in a small "worker's locker"...