Basement or ground slab: which is more sensible for the property situation?

  • Erstellt am 2024-01-28 19:38:06

ypg

2024-01-30 12:13:57
  • #1
Hedge? I would place the house all the way at the back and avoid blocking the south and west sides with a garage. Personally, I prefer to keep a courtyard that gives me options for window design, but maybe I'm just too complicated.
 

11ant

2024-01-30 14:01:10
  • #2
Oh, why is the house axis perpendicular to the slope?
 

hanghaus2023

2024-01-30 14:31:38
  • #3

After filling, it is no longer a slope. In my opinion, this is legitimate here, since it is built with a basement.
 

ypg

2024-01-30 14:40:15
  • #4
You misunderstood: the original poster is considering whether the slope allows for a basement or if they should build without one. See the headline ;)
 

11ant

2024-01-30 15:42:08
  • #5


Even if it is only a little slope, after generous filling, there is no money left.
I can only recommend to the OP my (not just local) posts on the topic of basement rules and basement questions, and I clearly see a partial basement or a moderate split level with a courtyard or a treatment of the terrain à la .
 

TobsBAU

2024-01-30 22:20:44
  • #6
Thank you for the further numerous contributions.


As already mentioned, that is exactly the question (basement or slab), especially from the overall cost perspective. I would proceed now by having a geotechnical survey made and use that to request quotes from excavation contractors and have them offer me various options:

    [*]Fill and compact the plot almost completely up to 155 to 156 m finished floor top edge
    [*]Partially fill the plot (footprint and terrace, optionally 1 m retaining wall) and compact up to finished floor top edge
    [*]Excavate basement pit, use excavation material for filling on the property, etc.

The comments on the alternative positioning of the garage/CP are great, but I cannot imagine that being approved (see attachment).


The placement is certainly a compromise of: view of castle/forest in the northeast, usability of the plot facing south, roof orientation for photovoltaics, etc.
When building the garage, privacy would already be given to some extent (see attachment, garage top edge should be at +158.75 m). The door on the neighbor’s house in the picture is not the main entrance door but a house entrance from the garage. The top two windows belong to the bathroom and bedroom. From there one will surely have a view of the terrace.
The two neighboring houses are oriented with their terraces to the northeast (view), which the currently discussed concept obviously deviates from (for the reasons mentioned).


What do you understand by "handling of the terrain à la Nordlys"?
Would you then construct the partial basement exclusively as a utility basement in the front area (towards the street)?
Regarding the split level, I could find hardly any information (additional costs, etc.). That would make sense in the northeast corner of the floor plan or (see attachment)?
 

Similar topics
08.01.2014Opinions on the hillside property22
21.04.2015Is a floor plan with a garage feasible on the property?29
15.08.2016Property - Building window - Location of house and garage44
20.12.2023Placement of house and garage on plot12
07.03.2017The neighbor's terrace borders the garage11
16.12.2018Floor plan design single-family house (city villa 140 sqm) on a slope with double garage495
10.02.2020Place house, garage / carport on the property93
24.04.2019Single-family house with garage on a gentle slope17
07.09.2020Trapezoidal plot: Initial ideas / improvement suggestions13
14.04.2020Steep slope property, please provide an assessment17
01.12.2020How to place buildings? House Terrace Garage Workshop24
08.03.2021Single-family house without a basement on a slope112
27.02.2021Location of city villa or single-family house on a plot with a wide street frontage63
08.06.2021Single-family house planning on a slope (2,700 sqm plot) - Experiences / Discussion42
19.08.2021Plot on a slope in the Munich outskirts - how to decide?54
20.10.2021Alignment of house and garage on the property18
23.03.2022Aligning the house on the plot: North-South / East-West, what should be considered?42
29.06.2023Position of garage on property, specification in development plan22
26.03.2025Orientation of single-family house + garage on west-east plot with street on the west18
03.08.2025South-facing plot 700 sqm, single-family house approx. 150 sqm, any ideas or input?43

Oben