Switch with separate installation for SFP / SFP+

  • Erstellt am 2020-05-25 23:19:33

FloHB123

2020-05-26 11:39:18
  • #1
Yes, but for what? Why more complexity again if it is not needed? Honestly, I still don’t understand it. So now I have to buy additional hardware to be able to use my 10Gbit network infrastructure? You are welcome to spend as much money on it as you want, but you really can’t seriously recommend that to anyone who asks whether they even need it and doesn’t have the things you mentioned (10Gbit adapter for a notebook, large NAS with 8 or more hard drives) and at least doesn’t mention it.
 

Appel2000

2020-05-26 13:09:53
  • #2
So let me summarize:

As long as I don't have devices that support 10 Gbit (I don't have any), wiring between the switches with SFP/SFP+ doesn't make sense.

Furthermore, if possible, pull everything to one location and avoid two separate units (later rental aside, it is anyway excluded to third parties).

Is that correct?
 

rick2018

2020-05-26 13:16:59
  • #3
10gbit only has limited connection with sfp+. You are totally fixated on sfp and sfp+. You might as well just connect the switches with the regular rj45 ports...

Yes, everything central. Whether you rent out later does not change the situation. In your initial plan, your second switch was also connected to the first one. You can separate just as easily/difficultly with a central solution. So please do it centrally. It is "best practice" for a single-family house and the right choice for you as a relatively inexperienced user.
 

Tassimat

2020-05-26 20:53:15
  • #4
: Just do what said perfectly, briefly and concisely:

As well as

So, if for some reason it absolutely must be two switches on two floors, then lay a plain Cat7 duplex cable between your switches. With that, you can already connect 10Gbit cheaply today. I predict that in 10 years you will easily achieve 40Gbit or even 100Gbit per line. Feasibility has been proven and it will definitely come. The demand and market for it is huge.

So, whether you use an SFP+ port or a native Ethernet port is completely irrelevant. Just don’t use fiber optic, it only makes it complicated. Simply Cat-7 duplex everywhere and both the 1-switch and the 2-switch solution can be easily implemented.

: I can only unconditionally agree with you as well.
 

untergasse43

2020-05-27 13:34:26
  • #5
To summarize:

SFP = option to send 1 Gbit over copper OR fiber. Longer distances or between buildings = fiber. Shorter distances and inside the building = copper (and you can just use a normal RJ45 port in that case. You also need to be careful because often the SFP ports are shared with a normal RJ45 port, meaning you lose one RJ45 port when using SFP.

SFP+ = option to send 10 Gbit by default over the media mentioned above in the cases mentioned above.

How you do it structurally, i.e. a central 10 GbE (core) switch to which the other two switches and e.g. a NAS with 10 GbE are connected, or simply both switches connected to each other with 10 GbE, can be considered and decided when you know what you want to use.

IF I were building new anyway, I would avoid creating a bottleneck between the switches and directly use SFP+ with fiber or copper. No one knows what you might want to do later. Maybe you want to use MoIP someday and then you’re stuck. There are many applications. In the past, people also thought that 64 kbit ISDN internet was enough for everything. My work computer has a 10 GbE card and is connected directly to the core switch because I almost exclusively work with data on the NAS. But everyone does it according to their taste.
 

blackm88

2020-05-27 19:02:17
  • #6


Hopefully the NAS is not the bottleneck then...
 

Similar topics
26.04.2016Front door with frosted glass20
18.12.2016Infrared glass heating26
22.07.2020Glass or louvered roof as a terrace covering56
28.11.2017Foundations for terrace roofing aluminum / glass11
03.09.2024Is a TAE socket no longer needed?67
28.09.2021What is the cost of the glass terrace roof?56
02.08.2019Bullet-resistant glass31
09.11.2021Terrace roofing, PC roof/glass, awning under glass?!17
22.07.2020Which switch with POE and 16 or 24 ports20
07.03.2022How to connect an outdoor camera? LAN, power or battery25
13.10.2020Satin glass or frosted glass?33
19.05.2021Glass sliding door with recessed handle + own handle bar20
10.10.2021Shower partition tiled or glass?28
13.05.2023Planning electrical systems to be future-proof257
08.08.2022Shower wall not made of glass, thin and stable34
14.07.2022Technical room / Router / Access Points / Switches99
11.03.2022small NAS for home use17
05.04.2023Cost estimate for glass stair railing23
15.08.2022Kitchen drawer side panels made of glass experiences21

Oben