Large office or a separate apartment?

  • Erstellt am 2021-01-16 12:09:52

WilderSueden

2021-01-16 21:48:49
  • #1

Parking spaces arranged one behind the other are often not recognized because the rear one is not accessible when someone is parked in front.

That should not be a problem. For two of my aunts, the option was a granny flat in the basement with a separate entrance from outside, but with a door inside the stairwell so the grandma could come up and see the grandchildren without leaving the house.
Basically, I see little advantage in adding the granny flat on the ground floor. You then need a kitchen and bathroom in the separated unit, which costs space and thus money. Overall, your ground floor will then be large, and that affects both floors. We are currently planning with a study downstairs and a work/guest/spare kids’ room upstairs and already have the problem that our ground floor is half a room too small and the upper floor half a room too large. A complete second housing unit requires even more space.
Oh yes, and about sharing an office—I wouldn’t do that. You do quite a lot of phone calls when working from home, sometimes for a long time. Having quiet is definitely pleasant.


To quote the basement rule by : For every 20cm difference in height, you pay 10% of the basement not to build it. At 1.5m, a slab foundation usually no longer makes sense, and at 1m it’s questionable. Especially in view of your plans to squeeze a granny flat into the ground floor.
 

haydee

2021-01-16 21:55:09
  • #2
Don’t bend yourselves. Often the space requirement on the ground floor is larger than on the upper floor. Rarely does the plot allow for a corresponding extension. If the granny flat is to be suitable for disabled seniors, you have a different space requirement. Check what is possible once you have your plot. I wouldn’t compromise and take flexibility just because it might be nice someday. Regardless, I would plan for 2 offices. Rather smaller. With a large one, you might disturb each other. No idea if the driveway can be approved as a parking space. Actually, the garage would no longer be accessible because of it.
 

11ant

2021-01-17 00:38:26
  • #3
So: "to not build it" is wrong, it must be: "whether built or not."
 

ypg

2021-01-17 01:59:19
  • #4
I don't think it's fundamentally bad (but rather good) to create a separate unit for the offices. However, I must also say right away that I don't think it's good if this is done only because of bonuses or subsidies. I or we as taxpayers have to support it, and if no immediate rental housing is created, I actually don't see why I should help finance it. A separate unit is wise in itself, to gain distance from the domestic environment. But how is it if children have to be cared for in the main apartment? As a teacher, do you want to unlock two front doors in the evening when you just want to quickly correct dictations? And my predecessors say it: it is already difficult to realize your own needs on one property – so what about the sensible space of a granny flat? For you two, an expanded attic would actually suffice, which hardly affects your finances noticeably. So why tie yourself to the burden of a granny flat?
 

Kati2022

2021-01-17 09:50:10
  • #5
Good morning,
thank you for the numerous replies.
Yes... that would not be a knockout for the 2nd residential unit.
In our apartment building (same municipality, built in 2012) there are double parkers in the underground garage. The cars (owned by the same apartment owner) are parked one behind the other and block each other’s exit. Wouldn't that be a similar situation?

Since I don’t have mandatory presence times in the office, I can organize my time myself and decide when I work. Usually it’s in the evening when my husband no longer works and can take care of the children.
Also, my husband only needs the home office sporadically. Most of the time he works on site at the company office.

Nowhere in the KfW guidelines does it say that the 2nd residential unit must be rented out. I think that was also intended by the legislator. Some people purposely rent small apartments to be able to work in peace. We don’t want to set up children’s rooms there, but private offices.
In old age, one would still be more flexible and could, for example, offer a separate living space to a caregiver (instead of moving directly to a nursing home).

As I wrote above: my husband and I never work together. One of us always has the task of taking care of the children.
 

ypg

2021-01-17 11:08:41
  • #6
Well, then one room is enough.
 

Similar topics
08.01.2014Opinions on the hillside property22
09.01.2017Newly built city villa with a granny flat and double garage72
01.03.2017Definition of a granny flat20
22.08.2018House construction with a granny flat - extension?27
02.11.2018Single-family house with a granny flat - ideas wanted11
09.12.2018Opinions on the single-family house with a granny flat floor plans54
25.10.2019Single-family house with a 75 sqm granny flat47
27.01.2020Building a single-family house with/without a basement on a small plot65
19.02.2021Floor plans of a single-family house with a granny flat, please tips and feedback62
08.05.2021New building with granny flat - general contractor restricts rental and KfW funding51
07.07.2021Floor plan single-family house with separate apartment as a 3-unit house69
08.08.2021Floor plan for a multi-generational house on a demanding plot16
31.08.2021Single-family new building: Planning a granny flat for future family expansion?47
02.09.2022Granny flat / Semi-detached house advantages64
02.09.2022Floor plans of a single-family house with a granny flat, 280 m2 on a pleasantly small 320 m2 plot86
09.01.2024Arrangement house and parking spaces - small plot - house with a granny flat27
28.01.2024Floor plan of a single-family house on a narrow plot24
11.02.2024Is a granny flat necessarily an (own) residential unit?16
12.03.2024Floor plan design for a single-family house with a granny flat51
01.10.2024Is the plot suitable for a narrow house for 5 people?43

Oben