Cutting out the house roof in the garage area - experiences

  • Erstellt am 2018-04-12 13:18:40

NanDe

2018-04-13 17:46:51
  • #1
So after the appointment the following dissatisfied realization:
The general contractor considers it disproportionate to tear off the roof for 25 cm of knee wall. Offers about 4 as a price reduction. That is ridiculous. According to the lawyer, it is also total nonsense regarding the disproportionality. We have an appointment with an expert next week.
What other disadvantages does the missing knee wall have, besides that I have less space in the attic (which is only supposed to be used as storage) and that the roof starts almost directly (after 2 rows of facing bricks) above the window and thus I have less light in the house and it looks cramped from the outside?
 

NanDe

2018-04-13 17:51:30
  • #2


The explanation was that the program automatically draws the garage 25cm lower than the house. In the plan, however, it is only 10cm.
 

11ant

2018-04-13 19:56:57
  • #3

Brazen nonsense. The mistake and the responsibility for it lie one hundred percent on his side. Rebuilding the garage lower including redesigning the driveway and changing the drainage will cost you far more than this consolation prize. And your argument about light and aesthetics is not wiped away by that. Nevertheless, it is not certain whether you will ultimately win in the first instance, and further construction is stalled. I would consider the additional effort of cutting out the roof at his expense plus 25 thousand for 25 cm forgotten knee wall a good mediation result.


The dimensions of his garage avatar/dummy should not be taken at face value in planning; he has to work with the real measurements. They have nothing to do with the type of door construction. Even though the context is preposterous, with

he clearly admits that he was always aware of the actual height of the garage. Stone, tar, feather, and then do the whole thing again :-)
 

NanDe

2018-04-16 20:10:20
  • #4
There is news... according to the general contractor, no knee wall was planned, but the 25cm mark is supposed to represent the bending point. Is that true or is he trying to fool us? In his opinion, the height problem now comes from a larger roof overhang, which he gave us as a gift. According to the plan 50cm, currently it is 75cm. He would have done that on his own because it looks nicer on the bungalow. How is a knee wall represented in a drawing? Is what he tells us true?
 

11ant

2018-04-16 22:15:47
  • #5
Whatever is supposed to bend off from something. In the drawing, a hatch pattern looks like it is meant to represent a row of stones or something similar. But even (just) a foot purlin would be possible there, nothing is really clearly visible.

25 cm more roof overhang at a 25° roof pitch naturally causes the eaves to shift by almost 12 cm.

A knee wall - which, however, is rather uncommon without residential expansion and also not typical at this height - can be recognized as a wall section under the foot purlin (unfortunately not really visible in this drawing). But lying on the floor of the attic, you can see if there is any "masonry" under the roof structure. The knee wall is measured from the top edge of the floor (only inconsistently, whether raw or finished).
 

Caspar2020

2018-04-17 06:31:55
  • #6
Is this the drawing for the building permit or for the execution planning?
 

Similar topics
05.11.2014Garage: design possibility of the roof, appearance14
15.08.2016Property - Building window - Location of house and garage44
16.04.2017Don't believe it's possible because the threshold is too high12
12.10.2016Kniestock lowered afterwards34
26.03.2017Raising knee walls: feasibility, costs, alternatives?10
13.06.2017Location of the house and garage on the property?14
06.01.2023House and garage, close the gap between both structures?12
02.02.2018Is the knee wall too low? What does the measurement refer to?22
13.02.2018House and garage - How best to place them on the properties?67
10.06.2018Build a house with a knee wall 75cm high or two full stories? Your opinion?17
27.08.2019Building plan stipulates knee wall is inadmissible16
27.12.2019Low ridge height results in a low knee wall55
05.10.2020Questions about the development plan (full floors, knee wall)11
30.12.2020Drempel yes/no, which height15
24.07.2021Extension or knee wall height increase?12
09.08.2023First high open space without knee wall26
02.09.2021The maximum height of the knee wall, everyone says something different.16
04.11.2021Floor plan design for a gable roof house (knee wall 2.20m) approximately 170 sqm42
14.09.2022Roof pitch and knee wall height when desiring a flat roof dormer26
03.06.2024Knee wall and windows for garage extension17

Oben