Saving 10,000 € in the year before buying a house is not enough. I agree with you on that. But I believe that very few households save 10,000 € per year after deducting vacation costs, etc. In my opinion, restricting your life before buying a house to save more is also not enough. Eventually, you want to live again and not just for the house. You also don't want to tell your child: Yes, we have a house, but no vacation or buying clothes. The 10,000 € should rather be there after buying the house.