Oh dear. Advantage: No problems with possible lightning strikes or potential differences. Sure, there is household insurance, but why should I bother redoing everything when I can prevent it with little effort (yes!)? My time ultimately also costs money.
Otherwise, I really lack the desire right now to keep playing the missionary here. Just because someone shouts loudly doesn't mean they're right.
On the topic of simplicity: The majority of homeowners who even remotely deal with the topic and go beyond a Fritzbox with a repeater often end up with Ubiquiti. Then you Google for 1-2 more minutes and find the right fiber optic cable in the Ubiquiti shop. Otherwise, there is nothing else to do except to bring the thing intact underground. Absolutely impossible task. Not.
You contradict yourself
Nope. When building a house, there are countless things that are far more complicated and require significantly more thought and decision-making effort; this here is a ridiculously trivial problem.
Whatever problem you have with the idea of "fiber optics," I'm out of here.