Who is responsible for the following defects?

  • Erstellt am 2019-07-08 20:18:13

Tassimat

2019-07-09 12:11:02
  • #1
So the first step is to go to the building authority to clarify whether the garage is allowed to remain there and whether you are allowed to move or build a new one at all.

Then obtain costs for the measures on the garage.

Then clarify what damages the neighbor really has on the house and who is responsible for them. From a legal point of view, the notary should be able to advise you.

Maybe an amount x can be withheld from the purchase price via the notary, from which all measures can be settled and the rest then goes to the seller.

No matter what happens, do not sign anything and do not let yourself be pressured.



You are supposed to say nothing? Then it is already clear that they are trying to push all costs onto you. Maybe they are in cahoots? Regardless, do not sign anything hastily without having clarified everything with all parties.
 

hampshire

2019-07-09 14:01:44
  • #2

Don't get involved in any "we shouldn't say anything" story, otherwise you'll quickly be involved in the dispute and end up with a poisoned neighborhood after you move in. Just ask the neighbors (not just the one) what you need to do to become a good neighbor. Then you'll learn quite a bit.
Furthermore, as already suggested, you can clarify the property and garage situation with the building authority.
Also have it confirmed that this is the only relevant communication - it could be that the old owner was a difficult person and there are further problems.
I would not buy the house without a clear clarification of this matter.
 

Mottenhausen

2019-07-09 14:50:01
  • #3
Even if everything is clarified, contractually agreed upon, the purchase price reduced by the costs, etc. etc., the renovation of the neighboring house can still become more expensive and the cost dispute starts all over again. To my knowledge, it is rather the rule than the exception that such things end up being significantly more expensive than estimated. Once you are the owner, you have all the trouble on your hands. The previous owner is long gone, pays nothing, and feels responsible for nothing anymore, while the new owner can offload half the renovation of his entire house onto you and is even justified in doing so. Stay away.
 

HilfeHilfe

2019-07-09 15:26:42
  • #4
Ever thought that the neighbor himself wants to buy and is disturbing the sale? That's why call the building authority.
 

11ant

2019-07-09 16:01:16
  • #5
Then leave it like that and look for a house that doesn't come with a "bonus" of neighbor disputes.
 

cschiko

2019-07-09 16:06:55
  • #6
So before it is exactly clarified who has to bear what or convert etc., I would not sign anything at all. Moreover, the question really arises whether one should even buy this property, as it carries a high potential for conflict. I would prefer to refrain from it unless it is otherwise an absolute dream property and a unique offer.
 

Similar topics
08.01.2014Where do we put the house and garage?10
17.05.2016Boundary construction garage and shed max. 9 meters - no more possible?20
13.05.2016Renovation costs39
21.11.2016Misplanning Bavaria - slope towards house and garage - instead of away23
19.12.2016Garage approved, but carport built23
03.03.2017Garage too deep due to local design regulations13
11.04.2017Building authority wants site inspection114
12.04.2017Garage price in the purchase contract from the notary is lower18
04.08.2017Bricking up the garage. Tips?21
02.05.2018Right to information from the notary even after purchase?43
11.05.2018Garage: What does "attached" mean? Does it mean that the masonry is connected?15
24.09.2019Union construction obligation for building a garage10
02.06.2020Notary contract amendment of the right of way10
22.06.2020Neighbor is building a garage deeper than the development plan specifies10
30.01.2021The building authority rejects the building application because the house is planned too far back86
05.02.2021Is renovating old buildings worthwhile?42
05.02.2023Floor plan optimization, renovation of a two-family house into a single-family house, built in 195731
26.03.2025Orientation of single-family house + garage on west-east plot with street on the west18
19.11.2024Floor plan of a single-family house with 240m² including a 75m² granny flat and garage39
20.05.2025Garage, carport with bicycle shed - land planning22

Oben