Which stone for exterior wall

  • Erstellt am 2014-12-28 17:38:58

K1300S

2015-10-28 09:18:20
  • #1
I wouldn’t know why anyone would want thicker masonry than statically required. It costs more money and floor space without providing any practical benefit.

It feels like nowadays buildings are mostly constructed with aerated concrete plus insulation. But since aerated concrete is less load-bearing than calcium silicate brick, the walls are usually thicker. Could that be the reason?

Best regards

K1300S
 

sirhc

2015-10-28 10:55:51
  • #2
I have 2 construction performance descriptions so far, and both are based on 17.5 cm aerated concrete + 16 cm insulation + exterior plaster. The walls in the examples are not made of sand-lime brick and are not thicker... and the structural engineer in the family told me: have 24 cm masonry offered to you and stick with the 16 cm insulation. That is where my question comes from...
 

K1300S

2015-10-28 12:54:25
  • #3
Then have the structural engineer explain to you why you should do that. As long as there are no concrete reasons (soundproofing, earthquake protection, ...) for it, I would leave it.
 

sirhc

2015-10-28 12:56:02
  • #4
The specific reason, namely soundproofing, actually exists. A railway track borders the property directly.

It might then possibly be interesting to compare 17.5 cm KS with 24 cm aerated concrete combined with the same insulation in terms of noise protection as well as overall insulation.
 

alexm86

2015-10-28 13:05:39
  • #5
Why don't you just ask the "befriended structural engineer" or your architect? And on what basis did you obtain the offers? There must be some basis after all.
 

sirhc

2015-10-28 13:11:02
  • #6
I have asked general questions regarding wall construction here. Should I unsubscribe just because I know a structural engineer? I do not have any offers but, as mentioned, various service descriptions from companies in the region (there are 3, not 2 as first stated). I have simply assumed/claimed that the "thin" wall which is not KS plus insulation is the cheapest option because, according to my understanding, the standard is listed in the service descriptions and more is always possible for an additional charge.
 

Similar topics
19.10.2010Poroton T14 or aerated concrete climate standard PP211
07.09.2012Single-layer masonry vs. double-layer masonry with ETICS19
28.10.201236 cm Ytong exterior wall, solid construction, mold formation, insulation37
25.02.2013Aerated concrete or Poroton or sand-lime brick?10
06.02.2017Insulate new construction 36.5 aerated concrete?60
05.08.2014New single-family house (KFW70)/aerated concrete vs. sand-lime brick/what to use?71
27.03.2014Interior walls upper floor lightweight construction instead of masonry?12
07.03.2014No construction company found that...13
23.07.2015Walls made of aerated concrete27
04.08.2017Exterior walls made of aerated concrete, interior walls made of calcium silicate brick - yes or no?11
11.01.2018Partition wall thickness for duplex house. Structural engineer plans 17.5 cm14
29.04.2018Bungalow made of aerated concrete - experiences? DIY beginner questions!34
01.02.2021Y-Tong (aerated concrete) - quality building material? (sound insulation!)91
29.12.2020Y-Tong vs Concrete without extra insulation in practice (heating costs)38
08.05.2019Aerated concrete or sand-lime brick with external thermal insulation composite system (ETICS) made of polystyrene29
15.01.2023Masonry from Ytong 24 or 30 for single-family house?53
25.01.2020Which material is suitable for the shell construction (thermal and sound insulation)?20
18.07.2021Unfilled bricks and soundproofing - looking for experiences36
11.02.2021Structural engineer needed for rough assessment of load-bearing capacity25
27.06.2023Is sound insulation according to DIN 4109-1 sufficient for a mid-terrace house?19

Oben