Opinions Expertises Evaluation House Plan

It's fun to play around like this. So don't let anyone talk you out of it here. My impression is that your approach is inspired by an external form and then you drew the spaces inside it. Put the drawing aside for a moment and think about how you want to live with your family. Who likes to do what, how do you meet, what are your routines... Then review your draft again according to these criteria. If it holds up: Go for it.

For such a large house, I miss generosity, I am not a fan of many corners and edges.

I had one year of architecture in school and kept drawing a lot. Ultimately, an architect was able to shape our wishes for living better on the existing plot than we ever could have ourselves.

To the budget skeptics: We first looked at what the ideal house for our life would be. Then we saw how to come closest to it within a manageable budget. Now construction is underway and the basic idea is being implemented.

No budget skeptic Here come more castles in the air than castles with a matching budget

About the floor plan What ceiling heights do you have? The staircase is somewhat long

The proportions of the rooms don’t fit. Children’s bathroom or 3rd bathroom on the ground floor is bigger than Child 1’s. Child 2’s room is terribly laid out. The children’s rooms are tiny. This is not a 140 sqm house for 5 people

Upper floor I suggest closing off the balcony to the children’s area and redistributing. The children don’t need the huge terrace. It shouldn’t totally ruin the exterior view either. It is also covered and a support is planned

The master bathroom is huge. I would reduce it and convert the dressing room into a proper walk-in closet. Hardly any cabinets fit in the walk-in closet and the bedroom The parent needs a different access. If you like oversized bathrooms, check out the bathroom of Huf Haus in Hannover Langenhagen

The air space is too small to have an effect. It doesn’t feel spacious. Keep in mind air spaces transmit all noises from below to above. First it will bother the children, later you

The staircase is wow indisputable. It needs space on the ground floor but doesn’t appear so on the upper floor. The narrow gap looks intentional but poorly executed. The hallway belongs to the glass side Parent and children area swap

Ground floor Close the air space to the basement Entrance hallway huge. However no wardrobe and so convoluted that it doesn’t work

Every door takes up space and your pantry has many square meters but very little usable area. Remove 1 door

Swap kitchen and living room. The kitchen belongs closer to the dining area. Appearance is one thing, but functionality is what makes a house livable

Draw your desired furniture to scale by hand on every floor plan. Imagine how you carry every fork from the kitchen to the dining table. Bring the children’s rooms to life. Build the ball run, then the train, then the friends Place stroller, tricycle, Maxi Cosi at the entrance, later the daughter’s shoe collection

Look at show homes. It lacks proportions. It lacks impact.

No budget skeptics Here come more castles in the air than castles with a matching budget

That may be so - nevertheless, we do not know the financial starting position. Some only take out a loan because it is so cheap and meanwhile let their assets make money.

There is a lack of proportions. There is a lack of impact.

Sounds a bit harsher than my assessment above, but it sums it up well.

Sims house ... Lego house ... does there always have to be a beating first as an initiation ritual here if someone doesn’t open their thread properly through the official channels - what’s so bad about spontaneously sketching what you’ve smoked at first? - that can not only be funny, but you can also develop something with substance from it!

If such clumsy-looking drawings come from someone who has already built two houses - which is a good start, as it is known that you are supposed to build the third house for yourself first - that only confirms my poor opinion of joke-related software ;-)

I didn’t understand the inclination of the attic exterior walls in the first place (unless a really spacey Sims look is intended) and secondly I still lack the idea of the construction, first of all at all and secondly also economically feasible.

Now I’m curious about the dry facts from the questionnaire and hopefully the plot is not far below 600 sqm.

It's fun to play around like this. So don't let anyone talk you out of it here.
My impression is that your approach is inspired by an outer form and then you drew the rooms into it.
Put the drawing aside for a moment and think about how you want to live with your family. Who likes to do what, how do you meet, what are your routines...
Then check your design again according to these criteria. If it holds up: Go for it.

For such a large house, I miss the spaciousness. I'm not a fan of many corners and angles.

I had one year of architecture in school and kept drawing a lot. Ultimately, an architect was able to better shape our wishes for life on the existing plot than we ever could ourselves.

To the budget skeptics: We also first looked at what the ideal house for our life would be. Then we saw how to come as close as possible to that within a manageable budget. Now it is currently being built and the basic idea is being implemented.

Ganz genau wollte unbedingt die S-Fassade mit den 2 übereinanderliegenden „L“ auf der Terrassenseite haben. Danach hat sich quasi das ganze Haus gerichtet.
Zum anderen wollte ich die gerade Treppe dies zusammenzubringen war gar nicht so einfach.

Questionnaire would not be a luxury

Is there even a plot of land?
What does the development plan say, or in the case of Par. 34, the municipal council?

That may be so - nevertheless, we don’t know the financial situation. Some people only take out a loan because it is so cheap and meanwhile let their assets earn money.

Sounds a bit harsher than my assessment above, but it gets the point across well.

No, we don’t know the initial situation.
There are also people who pay for their house in cash, but they are rare.
Even with pure own labor, it costs more than some single-family houses here in the forum.
I hope the OP has a plot on which he is allowed to build like that. Regardless of whether it's that big or reduced and how the interior will be.

Unfortunately, it has to be tough. Very few react to cotton wool balls. After all, often a castle in the air is being challenged.