Massive building vs. Prefabricated building

  • Erstellt am 2019-05-08 11:13:01

11ant

2019-05-09 01:36:50
  • #1

I would by no means describe stone houses with ETICS as "massive": they are usually built from "load-bearing interior walls as exterior walls," but even with a Wonderbra, a 17.5 cm wall remains a 17.5 cm wall. If already a "wall" made of pure stretcher bonds, then at least one stone thick, please! - but in my opinion, that is popular nonsense.

Analogous to External Thermal Insulation Composite Systems, prefabricated house wall panels could actually be called "Thermal Insulation Integral Systems," since basically an insulation between rafters is placed vertically—just something to "let sink in."


If I made you happy, it was worth it—because for a moment I was actually tempted not to send the post at all: hardly anyone wants to hear the truth (that the question of which stone is the stone of the wise is only hallucinated relevance); the audience is mostly "calibrated" (or better said: miscalibrated) to the truths "Faction X is right" or "Faction Y is right." But nobody— not even me, hehe—at least not as long as it is linked with "or." Because, as one man's owl is another man's nightingale—and it shall remain so.

The "nice" thing is: granted the only true answer to the question "which wall building material" has been found—then we cannot happily and contentedly go home like Piggeldy and Frederick. Instead, the drone goes on: heating, ventilation, hot water preparation; wire mesh panel—hedge—gabion; did I actually mention this month that I prefer two single gates to one wide gate? *duck and run*
 

hampshire

2019-05-09 07:33:57
  • #2

Huge plus for the open window! And the construction of forced-ventilated Tupperware boxes is being promoted. I'd much rather have a design that allows good air even with temporarily closed windows. Besides temperature, for me, humidity, particulate matter, smell, air movement, type of heat source, and low pollutant levels play a role. That's what I call indoor climate.
We trusted the wooden construction to be better. There is no claim to "correctness" in this; the OP asked for reasons for the decision.
 

Tego12

2019-05-09 07:58:11
  • #3
Phew, it’s getting philosophical again... The wall construction doesn’t matter for ventilation... Because no matter the wall construction, you have to pass a blower door test anyway... In other words, the ventilation demand, whether manual or automatic, is exactly the same.

Your timber construction is just as much a Tupperware box as any other modern house. Unfortunately, pretty marketing phrases don’t help there The air quality is not a bit better or worse, you have to ventilate just as much or as little. Whether you want to ventilate manually or automatically is a matter of personal preference...

If something affects the humidity, it’s the living habits (drying laundry etc..), or to a very small extent the interior plaster. The wall construction has exactly zero effect, how could it, ...
 

hampshire

2019-05-09 08:03:31
  • #4

He spoke out of ignorance of the construction - better to philosophize instead.
A blower door test does not have to be carried out.
 

Tego12

2019-05-09 08:10:06
  • #5
That is of course unfortunate for you, because with a Blower Door Test you can often find weak points and construction defects quite well. Regardless of the test (you are right, it is not mandatory, but has mostly become standard), it is legally required by the Energy Saving Ordinance that the building envelope is airtight ... test or no test. Either your envelope is airtight by definition (or as you would say, Tupperware), or your builder is not adhering to current laws....
 

hampshire

2019-05-09 08:17:36
  • #6
...or we want it that way, do it that way and are allowed to do it that way.
 

Similar topics
09.09.2010Ventilation system in the new building, yes or no?39
24.06.2014Decentralized controlled residential ventilation so expensive?38
06.01.2017Quiet decentralized ventilation for new single-family house73
06.11.2018New construction 2014: Problems with high humidity in the basement15
26.04.2016Warm bedroom in the house with ventilation including heat recovery24
20.01.2018Significantly high humidity in the cellar10
27.02.2018Too high humidity in the apartment. 60-70% in winter33
18.03.2024Attic problem. High humidity - Controlled residential ventilation?39
06.04.2023Experience ventilation roller shutter box: Aereco Zuroh 10015
25.08.2020Blower-Door-Test result (n50=1.13)49
29.03.2020Low humidity room climate (25%)19
14.06.2020Ventilation in summer without controlled residential ventilation is problematic19
21.11.2020Humidity 60% Masonry damp23
06.05.2021Alternative to central/decentralized ventilation61
11.09.2021Healthy Building - What is important?59
25.11.2021Getting rid of moisture from the shell construction - how to ventilate and other topics18
04.11.2022Result of blower door test KfW 5521
24.11.2022High humidity despite decentralized ventilation system16
21.06.202320% humidity in KFW 40+ new construction113
06.11.2023Very high humidity in all rooms50

Oben