L-shaped house on trapezoidal plot

The designs are all very closed off towards the street and very open towards the relatives. I can understand the first well, but on the second, I don't know if I wanted that. Other points: - the house will be relatively tube-shaped - I currently have a hard time imagining how one lives in it. Can you mark the intended rooms? - why sleep downstairs and live upstairs? I just can't wrap my head around that. If you already have a plot with a garden, why absolutely decouple the living room and kitchen from it completely? How do you imagine grilling on the weekend in nice weather? Second kitchen on the ground floor? Carrying all the food and the dirty dishes up and down the stairs? We don't even need to talk about age yet; I find the concept so far rather impractical.

Garage to the main road?

Are there no setback areas in A in front of the garage?

I would have spontaneously placed the L so that the relatives are at the back

Where does the family live? South of you? I like that. I would plan a counterpart but not make the mistake of turning your back to the south side. I don’t understand “Wohnen oben.” Don’t you want to enjoy the garden?

Planning a house with such a form specification (L) I consider a heavy burden for the poor planning process. At the driveway from the district road (?) I have my doubts – why in all variants do you not want to use the local road (residential street ?) for traffic access? In a pure introduction thread, I would have expected more about the person, and waited with the house positioning until after the questionnaire. Incidentally, I would always also develop an option "building composition under (partial) use of the existing building" – a two-hundred-year age of the house alone is, in my eyes, not yet a sufficient contraindication. Whether the "reversal" of the classic floor distribution is a description of the current state or a target specification has not yet become clear to me. Since you unfortunately write of no lake view and the plot is not visibly significantly sloped, I do not follow this "reversal." Where does the view from a living room sofa on an upper floor wander to?

My first idea was not to address the L at all. With 120 m2 on 2 floors, that makes little sense. I also planned the garage from the [Anliegerstrasse]. I will wait for answers from the TE. He is still enjoying the sun. ;)