Haus123
2024-05-04 11:06:45
- #1
It is like that with many people who see the "big" loan and have fear or respect of the debt. What is mostly overlooked, however, is the fact that basically (except for one installment to be paid for the use of the property similar to rent) absolutely nothing changes, since the debt is matched by an identical asset plus equity share. And thus, you are just as poor or rich as without the property.
That is just one part of the story. The difference to renting is that even if the interest rate roughly corresponds to the rent (roughly realistic at the current level of equity put in), with a house you have the "shame" of having to sell it in case of job loss plus moving, because a) the loan installment is higher than the cold rent due to the additional repayment and b) the equity invested is tied up in the house and can no longer serve as a liquidity reserve. This means that in the worst case you might have a net worth of 500k but still have to sell because you run out of liquidity. With the same rental property, on the other hand, you can sell your stocks or dissolve your overnight money and keep living there.
Depending on the cycle in which this mishap occurs, you also burn through acquisition incidental costs (very painful if after only 2-3 years) and in the worst case a loss in value and thus significant loss of wealth. You have to see it realistically: job loss does not usually happen in the boom phase (or you find adequate replacement more easily then) with generally rising real estate prices, but rather in a recession (where finding adequate replacement is difficult) with rather stagnant to falling real estate prices. The good 10 years after the financial crisis have somewhat clouded people’s judgment there.
Therefore, I advise especially high earners to be modest. A normal earner can find a comparable job at any time (at least currently), a top earner not necessarily. Beyond a certain level, there is also not much job protection left. Sure, there is usually a decent severance, but even that won’t last forever on a million-euro loan.
Nevertheless, I consider the single-family house with 750k quite appropriate in this specific case. A 500k loan is doable for you.