Green regulatory determination - Your opinion?

  • Erstellt am 2024-02-10 20:13:19

K a t j a

2024-02-12 16:01:54
  • #1

I have to completely disagree. We always adhere to the development plan and also have all the necessary permits for buildings etc.
So far, I cannot detect any violations from our neighbors either.
Maybe it varies regionally, so you should not generalize from your situation to others.
 

WilderSueden

2024-02-12 17:11:27
  • #2
Have fun trying to keep a large tree at 4m. That is simply not natural and harms the tree accordingly. I'm not saying anything against trees either, we have planted about 15, plus a whole bunch of small shrubs. This spring, bush trees for fruit are to be added. When that grows for a few years, it will be wonderful. But 4-5m is already quite tall and provides a lot of shade. That is completely sufficient for a small private garden. Planning for large trees completely misses the problem, and the fact that a fruit tree counts only as standard but not as half-standard can only be explained by a fetish of the authorities.
 

aero2016

2024-02-12 17:42:19
  • #3
Both are correct. And both ways often turn out to be more successful than the other in the end. You may like that or not, but for someone with an urgent concern, it is often the most pragmatic way to achieve their goal.
 

Musketier

2024-02-12 17:59:07
  • #4
I didn’t say that you didn’t stick to it, sometimes you also misinterpret it or overlook something.

For example, I have now taken another look at our development plan. I am actually capable of reading laws, but despite reading it several times, I can’t tell you how many trees and shrubs we should really have planted. In our rear part of the property (edge area), a tree must be planted every 10 m or 100 m² according to the species list. Additionally, 1 shrub every 4 m². That would probably be 2 trees for 17.5 m width. The depth of this area is not precisely defined, so it can only be roughly estimated. You can imagine how exactly measuring works on a 25,000 m² construction site on A3 paper.

Furthermore, for all properties, one ridge-transcending tree or a fruit tree must be planted for every 300 m² of property size. For just over 500 m² of property area, in my opinion, that would be one tree. Whether the trees from both areas are offset against each other or must be cumulatively planted, or whether the m² from the rear edge area is deducted from the rest of the property and thus we come under 300 m² remaining area… honestly, I don’t know. Then trees are required according to the species list. Above the species list, however, it says among other things (presumably for among others), which actually once again leaves the door wide open for free choice. Even if we had fulfilled the number and type of trees, I would never claim that we had fulfilled the development plan 100%. It’s simply too vague for that.



Then how do you come to the conclusion that the neighbors might not have read the development plan?

 

K a t j a

2024-02-12 18:39:12
  • #5
They didn’t build their houses themselves but had them built. Since so far no one has created an orchard meadow, one might suspect that they haven’t read the plan at all and have left everything to the respective company. But as I said, there is still time.
 

Similar topics
13.09.2014Multi-family house: arrangement of residential units, trees, etc.35
19.01.2018Clearing and preparation of land12
12.10.2015Plot with some special features - various questions34
18.04.2016Trees on desired plot, is felling allowed? Seeking advice10
25.07.2016Is a 3,000 sqm plot sensible?44
12.07.2017Heavily overgrown property - what is the best way to proceed?22
05.10.2017Property / Development Plan / Retaining Walls / Excavations17
15.08.2018Basic floor area ratio / floor area ratio for plots without a development plan: How to calculate? Experiences?18
23.07.2020Empty conduits on the property - ideas? - It's not too late yet :)103
24.10.2019Single-family house (10x8.8 sqm) on 437 sqm plot in Munich48
25.02.2020Assessment of property sought - Article 34 redevelopment11
06.05.2020Is the community required to develop if a development plan exists?20
03.06.20208 trees on the property between the power and telephone lines.31
21.09.2021Solar panel shading caused by neighbor's trees15
30.01.2022Plot 4500 m² (nursery) - preparation of development plan independently16
01.02.2022Who is responsible for the trees? Neighbor's fence behind the boundary10
27.06.2022North-West Facing Plot - Tips24
29.06.2023Position of garage on property, specification in development plan22
03.08.2024Nice plot of land, but is the development plan too restrictive?21
10.05.2025Which property would you choose? Single-family home with double garage44

Oben