Positioning of stair shaft in floor plan

  • Erstellt am 2025-08-16 14:39:34

GreenXL

2025-08-18 14:57:31
  • #1
Thank you for the comments on the wall design. The architect drew it that way, I think it's good. How would you do it?
 

ypg

2025-08-18 16:10:52
  • #2
As long as you like it, everything is fine and so on. It stands out because it was used earlier as a design element – nowadays still often in very small houses so that you can enter two rooms from the hallway. But contemporary design is straightforward. The staircase would also be more comfortable with straightforwardness, meaning 90-degree corners, as there would be more area to walk on. Is the architect over 60?
 

11ant

2025-08-18 18:54:52
  • #3

If eighty is the new sixty, then probably yes ;-)

I have once "tidied up" the ground floor, as I do not see the moral value of the slanted walls and the "light-flooded dirty corner" between guest room and pantry. Bundling the risers for ventilation stuff and automation stuff into one run is, in my opinion, more counterproductive than (for what?) advantageous and would probably mean pulling a box under the ceiling somewhere between points "2" and "3" roughly in a cross-section of 30/20. The best point would probably be near "1", but technically on the room side of the wall to the hallway. Above the ceiling of the ground floor, I then envision the ventilation ducts advancing towards the "room above the WC" and towards the "room above the pantry", while the automation and other electrics each march under the ceilings towards "3".
All this needs to be planned early, see also and as a warning example—not least for the idea of overbundling—in
 

11ant

2025-08-18 19:01:06
  • #4
Ceterum censeo, the four minutes should finally be raised back to ten minutes!
 

GreenXL

2025-08-19 08:36:57
  • #5

Thank you very much for the drawing!
Unfortunately, we would lose our small niche where a wardrobe was supposed to be placed.
In my opinion, this can only be reasonably accessed if the adjoining wall to the guest room is slanted.

I find the advantage of the slanted walls is that you don’t lose any room space; honestly, I wouldn't know how to solve it differently in the upper floor than with the slanted walls. But I am open to suggestions. :)
 

ypg

2025-08-19 13:16:36
  • #6
My floor plan-trained eye sees

a niche that is good for a plant or decorative stuff, but does not work as a wardrobe for 4 people.

On the contrary, you lose a corner with every slope, since furniture is built at 90 degrees. With every sloping wall, you will have one or two lost corners. Dust-catching corners.

The designer (or architect here) should plan properly with 90-degree corners. Then there are reasonable areas where a good wardrobe fits, the staircase gets enough space, and upstairs works without them. Why do other architects manage it and yours doesn’t? As already said: if necessary, you can take half corners, but don’t make a virtue out of it.
 

Similar topics
19.07.2018Draw the plan yourself? Do you necessarily need an architect?11
18.02.2011Architect totally messed up - experiences?17
06.10.2014Single-family house with split-level living area25
06.01.2015Where to place the staircase? Attic conversion hip-roof bungalow19
26.06.2015Floor plan question, stairs, window, orientation12
12.07.2016Floor plan question, garage, stairs33
17.10.2017Single-family house approx. 150 sqm floor plan - How to plan the staircase?65
10.11.2017House plan by architect 2 floors with basement18
24.09.2018City villa with straight staircase, open modern design, 140m²18
10.10.2019Single-family house by architect 150m² improvement suggestions and ideas wanted75
25.11.2019New single-family house approx. 174 m² floor plan architect55
15.08.2020Cupboard under the stairs or small storage room11
16.10.2020Planning recessed spotlights for hallway and wardrobe - tips62
25.11.2021Floor plan change single-family house 150 m² due to stairs36
08.08.2021Hidden passage in pantry - seeking experiences28
02.02.2022Staircase shifted by 10 cm, options?39
17.07.2022Floor plan: Door planning living room + pantry17
01.07.2023Layout question: Replace straight staircase with L-shaped staircase31
20.11.2024Floor plan EFH165 sqm first draft - Architect dissatisfied74
20.11.2024Is staircase DIN 18065 mandatory or not?82

Oben