Is a stair floor plan 2x1/4 spiraled + landing possible with a maximum of 2.4x2.4m?

  • Erstellt am 2017-06-13 10:27:14

ypg

2017-06-14 15:40:08
  • #1
The flight is interrupted by a landing, and the walking flow is not even. With you, this happens twice. In addition, you have a different number of steps in each staircase section. Landings and irregularities increase the risk of accidents. So with you, it’s doubled.

I would advise against a landing staircase or... changing the floor plan due to a different staircase shape. But then you basically start almost from scratch again, since I assume your stairwell is justified and cannot just be widened easily.



It is called a three-flight U-shaped staircase and is double winding or 2/4 winding or, as Robin says, 2 x 1/4. I googled it once.

By the way, the staircase shape is more common in medical practices, hotels, schools, or public buildings, as it - if properly built - requires a lot of space (because of the stairwell). There is then also a reasonable number of steps in the middle.

In a single-family house, I assume it is avoided because two steps, then 3 or 5, are dangerous in everyday routine.
 

mertmk3

2017-06-14 15:42:47
  • #2
Google spits out numerous different terms here.

I meant a half-turn staircase, at least that's what comes up when I enter "halbgewendelt" in Google.

/Edit: On the architect's drawing, it is a 2 x 1/4 turn staircase. The top and bottom steps are straight.

I hear that you would still prefer a 2 x 1/4 turn with 16 STG 18.44/26 and design it with a 1m raw construction width?!
 

RobsonMKK

2017-06-14 15:50:25
  • #3
I have my quite own way of thinking about stairs, for me they are a vehicle from top to bottom and vice versa. I personally would pay more attention to the materials.

Personally, I don't like the 2 landings. Normal landing stairs remind me more of apartment buildings, but I could also have that exclusively.
 

mertmk3

2017-06-14 15:55:41
  • #4
So my alternative is now a 2 x 1/4 spiral staircase with the following data:

16 RISERS 18.44/25.94
Step measure: 62.82cm
Staircase width rough construction: 100cm
Floor plan: 240cmx200cm

Is there any objection to this staircase?
 

11ant

2017-06-14 16:29:45
  • #5

That has already been well explained


No one in your family will have exactly 63 cm step length (or only by chance). One subconsciously adjusts to the difference from the "norm" while using the first steps. If the step length then changes in between – especially here because the landing length is not an integer multiple of the step length – then climbing the stairs requires attention (again subconsciously, but still needs computing power in the brain), which increases the risk of falling.


I am modest and also content with contributions aimed at avoiding errors


I don’t know your floor plan, from which alone I cannot say for sure whether I would prefer a half-turn staircase there. Turned or not – it should be uniform. Less because of the looks than because of the accident-free use even for the 1,001st time.


You can do that. But only either or: a staircase is either a secondary or a main element in the floor plan, but it must be clearly one or the other. Main or secondary element does not work. Very beautiful and interesting houses can be created by staging the staircase as a sculpture. My favorite pizza baker says: “A car starts at 150 hp.” This applies 1:1 to the minimum area per floor that a show staircase allows without compromises.


Wrapping around an elevator shaft has, in my opinion, quite its charm, and then the aspect of space consumption becomes relative.
 

mertmk3

2018-01-16 08:24:37
  • #6
Our staircase has a floor plan of 2.4mx2m. The width is 2.4m. So far, I had planned a running width of 1m, which would result in a stairwell width of 40cm. Would it be better to widen the running width to 1.1m and then have a stairwell with a width of 20cm? I think the stairwell is wasted space; a wider staircase could be more comfortable?
 

Similar topics
17.02.2012Floor plan - house with granny flat23
21.02.2012How do you find this floor plan?11
19.05.2012Floor plan: Please provide opinions on the ground floor draft14
14.08.2012Please give an honest opinion about our floor plan!!29
23.11.2012Rough cost calculation based on floor plan13
14.01.2013Floor plan of the fourth! :-)18
14.01.2013Opinions about the ground floor layout10
30.01.2013Floor plan over 200 sqm - What do the experts think about it?13
25.02.2013Single-family house, estimated costs and suggestions for the floor plan49
05.03.2013City Villa Floor Plan - Thank you for your feedback15
09.04.2013Layout suggestions, examples ...15
26.05.2013Your opinion on the floor plan for the ground floor28
20.06.2013Opinion on the floor plan of a planned Bauhaus building23
12.09.2013What do you say about our floor plan?15
12.08.2013Opinions on the "House on the Slope" floor plan requested31
26.08.2013Floor plan single-family house. Your suggestions are welcomed.17
04.09.2013Floor plan, living area too narrow, ideas / suggestions17
18.09.2013Help with the house floor plan, improvement suggestions?28
29.12.2014Floor plan ground floor + upper floor for semi-detached house29
05.09.2016Move exterior wall in floor plan?33

Oben