House price reasonable?!

is not a layman and is therefore right?!

We are not buying the house after all.
Only you can make the decision!
Is the house worth the purchase price from your point of view? Forget the supposedly objective calculations for a moment. What does your gut and your wallet say? Will you get a comparable offer in the future or have alternatives?

is not a layman and is therefore right?!

Correct, he is a certified surveyor.

Without intending to offend Dirk, he has a different perspective on the connections between the property and the existing building than, for example, a salesperson who deals with these matters daily. What do you think is the reason I have been repeatedly advising you (by now) to involve an expert?

Of course, the building is still under warranty, and this also transfers to the new buyer. But – who supervised and accompanied the construction of the house? Who carried out the acceptance(s)? And ... and ... and? There are many question marks, as you rightly recognized, which only an on-site inspection with expertise can answer. Everything else is groping in the dark, and I have been doing the job long enough by now.

Rhenish greetings

The question is whether you can get a BETTER house newly built for this money or not?

We also first (before the construction) looked for a younger existing property, but the prices (incl. all additional costs) in our region were sometimes so high that you could also build new for the money, which we are now doing.

That will be difficult because there are hardly any building plots and if you find any, they are relatively expensive.

Honestly, I've been asking myself that question the whole time as well. Opinions here vary greatly.. It's somehow not getting any easier for me..

and that is exactly the problem here and I am honestly starting to find it unbelievable....

Do you really believe that in a forum with mostly laypeople who have no connection to your property and have moreover never been in this house, you will get an accurate assessment?

I have experienced this quite often here, that users hope for personal decision-making help in this forum and then are surprised that they end up more confused, frightened, or clueless than before?

Welcome to the social media age, sometimes it’s better to trust your gut feeling or the human contact on site (with an expert, architect).....

If there are no similar properties for an approximate price, then you know the answer! Go for it and be happy!