Different Heating Concepts Compared

  • Erstellt am 2023-08-03 22:25:47

Alessandro

2023-08-08 09:06:39
  • #1
here is a comparison of the two systems:

 

RotorMotor

2023-08-08 09:22:19
  • #2
Uff, rarely have I seen such a bad comparison.

I would start to take apart the individual points now, but it's not even worth it.
 

Alessandro

2023-08-08 09:39:30
  • #3
Go ahead. Without any argumentation, it is of course easy to claim that the comparison is bad ;-) PS: the comparison refers to the new building with the corresponding heating load.
 

HeimatBauer

2023-08-08 09:48:26
  • #4
Is the "comparison" from a seller of air-to-air heat pumps or from a buyer who is now trying to justify their purchase?
 

Alessandro

2023-08-08 10:12:05
  • #5
The comparison comes from a manufacturer (of air-to-water heat pumps and air-to-air heat pumps) in cooperation with a prefab house provider.
 

RotorMotor

2023-08-08 10:18:50
  • #6
Where exactly did you get this graphic from? I really don't find anything good/right about it. You probably also need to distinguish much more what kind of air-to-air heat pump is being used.

but let's quickly go through: 1. Heating is more efficient with air-to-water heat pumps with the appropriate hydraulics. 2. Dehumidifying is both an advantage and disadvantage depending on whether you want it. You can't turn it off anyway. 3 and 4. Where is the difference for the customer between investment costs and installation costs? And having an indoor unit in every room is supposed to be cheaper than a few pipes in the screed? 5. Operating costs should be higher with air-to-air heat pumps due to disinfection of the indoor units 6. Air filter function? What does that have to do with heating? 7. Since when can an air-to-air heat pump produce hot water? 8. Space requirements. All those air-to-air heat pump indoor units don't require space? 9. Yeah okay 10. Funding eligibility changes constantly. What is the current situation anyway? 11. Comfort: Now it gets really bizarre. Here it is urgently necessary to distinguish between heating and cooling. And comfort in LL green? Despite drafts, noise, and so on?
 

Similar topics
08.01.2013Air heat pump with fireplace, water-bearing stove, hot water heating26
28.02.2012air heat pump, water-based fireplace stove, functioning, underfloor heating?12
25.06.2020Air heat pump or use gas and solar?300
02.09.2013Which heating system for prefab houses: air source heat pump, geothermal, solar, photovoltaic17
06.10.2013Experience reports air heat pump, wood stove, solar system, noises31
26.10.20132-family house KFW70 heating with air heat pump ventilation and exhaust ventilation14
11.02.2015Air heat pump and electricity consumption50
25.10.2015Which heating system? Air heat pump / Gas / Geothermal52
23.10.2015Prefabricated house heating: Gas / Air heat pump / Underfloor heating22
10.02.2016Is an air source heat pump sufficient for a harsh winter in the Black Forest?14
29.06.2016Gas or air heat pump experiences?44
24.01.2017Air heat pump vs geothermal energy, new build 400m233
01.03.2017Gas boiler or air heat pump13
10.11.2017Back payment air heat pump disaster, contracting party, electricity supplier11
24.01.2018Air heat pump and water-bearing fireplace - experiences12
06.06.2018Air heat pump in combination with water-carrying fireplace18
16.10.2018Air heat pump is not heating, but the hot water works28

Oben