Which heating system is currently the best?

  • Erstellt am 2012-09-10 23:49:54

Häuslebauer40

2012-09-12 17:15:59
  • #1
I'm actually only marginally interested in that... The first year is not representative anyway. The screed program alone already uses 6-7000 kWh
 

K.Brodbeck

2012-09-13 05:55:50
  • #2
I think what Charlie Brown is getting at is that at -20°, an air heat pump is a purely electric heater, i.e. you can also put electric heaters in it. An air heat pump only has a good efficiency at 'warm' temperatures; when you really need it (in winter), the efficiency is not that good.

lg

K.Brodbeck
 

Häuslebauer40

2012-09-13 06:30:38
  • #3
Yes, I know that myself. But it's not that dramatic. As I could observe in February, the heating element switched on at -10 degrees. Until then, the pump managed on its own. How many days a year do we already have below -10 degrees...
 

Bauexperte

2012-09-13 11:35:44
  • #4
Hello,


A lot of nonsense is told/written about air-to-water heat pumps, but that does not make it an electric heater.

As with everything in life, it is important that a reasonable planning of the system is in place and that the system installed matches the demand. If these conditions are met, the proportion of "supplementary heating" with electricity remains within an acceptable range. By the way, no heating system runs without electricity.

Kind regards
 

Der Da

2012-09-13 11:48:16
  • #5
Whereas with gas boilers, electricity costs are almost negligible. They are between 100 and 200 kWh per year for the circulation pump, ignition spark, and valve. Roughly speaking, about 50 € per year.
 

€uro

2012-09-13 21:16:26
  • #6
Formally speaking, this bivalence point sounds quite reasonable. Unfortunately, the fear of the dreaded heating element often leads to oversizing. The installer is happy because he has sold a more expensive device than might actually be necessary. The problems (lifespan, seasonal performance factor) usually arise mostly in partial load operation, especially near the heating limit, particularly with ON/OFF devices that cannot modulate. The days are irrelevant; what matters are the hours at the respective outside temperature. What seasonal performance factor is actually achieved?
Best regards
 

Similar topics
08.01.2013Air heat pump with fireplace, water-bearing stove, hot water heating26
07.10.2016Which heating is recommended for KfW 55?58
25.06.2020Air heat pump or use gas and solar?300
02.09.2013Which heating system for prefab houses: air source heat pump, geothermal, solar, photovoltaic17
11.02.2015Air heat pump and electricity consumption50
11.04.2015Would you take an air heat pump again? Looking for alternatives to air heat pumps18
23.10.2015Prefabricated house heating: Gas / Air heat pump / Underfloor heating22
10.02.2016Is an air source heat pump sufficient for a harsh winter in the Black Forest?14
29.06.2016Gas or air heat pump experiences?44
10.11.2017Back payment air heat pump disaster, contracting party, electricity supplier11
06.06.2018Air heat pump in combination with water-carrying fireplace18
27.11.2018Change heating "after" building permit?13
01.07.2019Which heating system for the 200 sqm new building?54
12.08.2019The agony of choice in heating16
17.11.2019Manufacturer heating / controlled indoor ventilation wanted10
08.06.2020Air-to-air heat pump vs air-to-water heat pump vs ring trench collector - differences50
08.12.2020Combination of air-to-air heat pump, air-to-water heat pump, solar thermal and photovoltaic system with storage20
15.12.2021Replace electric underfloor heating / alternative sought21

Oben